10th-man
CommunityDivergent gate for critical review
Education & Research#quality-gate#risk-analysis#divergent#document-review#critical-review#devil-advocate
Authorfabioabr
Version1.0.0
Installs0
System Documentation
What problem does it solve?
Devil's advocate guidance for rigorous critique of any document, proposal, or analysis, forcing explicit consideration of missing justifications, blind spots, and risks. The approach uses a two-phase review: Phase 1 generates divergent, hostile questions; Phase 2 evaluates responses and assigns a structured verdict and score to drive improvements.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Enforces a two-phase review workflow: divergent questioning followed by evaluative scoring.
- Generates phase-1 questions to surface gaps, inconsistencies, and edge cases.
- Produces phase-2 scores across divergent coverage, grounding in sensitive areas, and antipatterns to guide mitigation.
- Useful for gatekeeping reviews, audits, briefs, designs, and strategic proposals in research, product, and policy contexts.
Quick Start
Provide a critical review of the input document, applying the 10th-man divergent gate approach to surface missing considerations and risks.
Dependency Matrix
Required Modules
None requiredComponents
Standard package💻 Claude Code Installation
Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.
Please help me install this Skill: Name: 10th-man Download link: https://github.com/fabioabr/ia-ws/archive/main.zip#10th-man Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.
Agent Skills Search Helper
Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 471,000+ vetted skills library on demand.