skills.rest
BMS-kmusial
BMS-kmusialCOMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

10x-impl-review-ci

Reviews pull requests against implementation plans in GitHub Actions CI.

Updated May 23, 2026
Search Tags:#automation#code review#pull request#github actions#test coverage#ci#plan drift
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/BMS-kmusial/bms-stream-monitor --skill 10x-impl-review-ci-bms-kmusial
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: 10x-impl-review-ci
Source: https://github.com/BMS-kmusial/bms-stream-monitor/tree/main/.claude/skills/10x-impl-review-ci
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/BMS-kmusial/bms-stream-monitor --skill 10x-impl-review-ci-bms-kmusial

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Teams using plan-driven development lack an automated way to verify that a pull request actually implements what its plan declared. This Skill runs a non-interactive implementation review inside GitHub Actions, comparing the PR diff against the plan's commitments and publishing an auditable verdict. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Plan Drift Detection: Discovers the plan file under context/changes/, cross-references changed files against planned files, and flags MATCH / DRIFT / MISSING / EXTRA per planned change. - Parallel Evidence Gathering: Spawns three subagents covering plan drift, safety/quality/pattern compliance, and test coverage, then runs the plan's non-test automated checks (lint, build, typecheck). - Auditable Output Contract: Writes a structured impl-review.md report with a seven-dimension verdict table, commits it to the PR branch with [skip ci], posts inline review comments on flagged diff lines, and publishes a summary PR comment. - Use Case: A team labels a PR with impl-review; the workflow reviews the PR against its plan, commits the report, and gates the merge on a REJECTED verdict unless an impl-review-override label is present. ## Quick Start Ask the agent to run the 10x-impl-review-ci skill on this pull request in GitHub Actions to review the implementation against its plan and post the verdict.

Frequently Asked Questions about 10x-impl-review-ci

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I automatically review a pull request against an implementation plan in CI?▼

Run this skill inside GitHub Actions via claude-code-action on pull request events. It discovers the plan under context/changes/, compares the PR diff against planned changes, commits a review report to the branch, and posts inline and summary comments with a verdict.

How does the skill find which plan a pull request implements?▼

It searches the PR diff for plan files matching context/changes/<change-id>/plan.md, picking the newest by reverse-lexicographic sort. A Plan: path line in the PR description overrides the convention, and if no plan exists it posts a neutral comment and exits cleanly.

Does this work in a monorepo with multiple workspaces?▼

Yes. Plan discovery uses a glob that matches context/changes/ at the repo root or under any workspace subtree, and the review report path is derived from the plan's own directory, so reports land beside the plan regardless of location.

Can the review block a pull request from merging?▼

The skill itself always exits 0; gating lives in the workflow. A post-review step parses the verdict from the committed report and fails the check on REJECTED unless the PR carries the impl-review-override label.

Why does the review commit include [skip ci] in the message?▼

The [skip ci] marker prevents the bot's own push from retriggering the same workflow, which would cause an infinite recursion loop. The skill verifies the marker is present before pushing and aborts loudly if it is missing.

What happens if posting inline review comments fails?▼

Inline posting is non-fatal. Failed findings are moved into the summary PR comment, and if every inline call fails the summary shows all findings with a visible warning. The committed report remains the complete audit trail.

Related Skills

Explore More Software Engineering Skills→
redblacktreeredblacktree
1

source-command-validate-plan

Validates implementation against plan success criteria and generates a structured validation report.

Community
Intermediate
yxc023yxc023

todo-triage

Triage code-review todos by approving, skipping, or modifying each finding.

Community
Advanced
sakurosakuro
2

merge-pr

Merge GitHub pull requests with the gh CLI after validating CI checks and approvals.

Community
Intermediate
ConsiliencyConsiliency
2

phase-loop

Bridges harness TUIs to the repo-local phase-loop runner for bounded roadmap execution.

Official
Advanced