adversarial review gate — a dedicated, read-only skeptic dispatched after an impl wave, before merge-to-main / bead-close, whose only job is to disprove "done." Hunts stub bodies, mock-the-unit tests, unverified acceptance criteria, unreproducible runtime claims, composition gaps. Distinct from /check (which interrogates the plan, pre-impl).

Name: adversarial review gate — a dedicated, read-only skeptic dispatched after an impl wave, before merge-to-main / bead-close, whose only job is to disprove "done." Hunts stub bodies, mock-the-unit tests, unverified acceptance criteria, unreproducible runtime claims, composition gaps. Distinct from /check (which interrogates the plan, pre-impl).
Availability: InStock
Author: azigler

Community

Stop false “done” with a read-only skeptic

Software Engineering #quality gate #adversarial review #evidence-based findings #pre-merge validation #test integrity #code scrutiny

Authorazigler

Version1.0.0

Installs0

System Documentation

What problem does it solve?

It prevents teams from shipping or closing an implementation wave when the delivered code, tests, or acceptance evidence are misleading, incomplete, or unverifiable.

Core Features & Use Cases

Adversarial post-implementation audit: reviews delivered code to disprove the claim that the work is complete.
Evidence-first verdicts: requires findings with file:line locations and a clear SHIP / FIX-FIRST / REJECT outcome.
Targets common quality failures: hunts stub bodies, mocked tests that don’t test real code, missing error paths, and composition gaps in user-facing surfaces.

Quick Start

Dispatch the /scrutinize gate right after an impl wave with real implementation, then require the reviewer’s verdict and file:line findings to be appended to the impl bead notes before merging.

Dependency Matrix

Required Modules

None required

Components

Standard package

💻 Claude Code Installation

Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.

Please help me install this Skill:
Name: adversarial review gate — a dedicated, read-only skeptic dispatched after an impl wave, before merge-to-main / bead-close, whose only job is to disprove "done." Hunts stub bodies, mock-the-unit tests, unverified acceptance criteria, unreproducible runtime claims, composition gaps. Distinct from /check (which interrogates the plan, pre-impl).
Download link: https://github.com/azigler/dotfiles/archive/main.zip#adversarial-review-gate-a-dedicated-read-only-skeptic-dispatched-after-an-impl-wave-before-merge-to-main-bead-close-whose-only-job-is-to-disprove-done-hunts-stub-bodies-mock-the-unit-tests-unverified-acceptance-criteria-unreproducible-runtime-claims-composition-gaps-distinct-from-check-which-interrogates-the-plan-pre-impl

Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.

View Source Repository

Agent Skills Search Helper

Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 471,000+ vetted skills library on demand.