skills.rest
Noetfield-Systems
Noetfield-SystemsOFFICIAL
Explore all skills by this author →
WebsiteGitHub

advisor-external-critic

Enforces four invariants and forbidden-topic rules for external advisor critic replies.

Updated Jun 20, 2026
Search Tags:#governance#review#advisor#guardrails#critique#invariants#brief
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Noetfield-Systems/SourceA --skill advisor-external-critic-noetfield-systems
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: advisor-external-critic
Source: https://github.com/Noetfield-Systems/SourceA/tree/main/agent-skills/shared/advisor-external-critic
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Noetfield-Systems/SourceA --skill advisor-external-critic-noetfield-systems

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? It keeps external advisor critique replies consistent with a locked discussion track by enforcing four invariants and blocking forbidden topics such as batch drains, 972 chases, and stealth architecture changes. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Invariant Enforcement: Every reply must uphold the four invariants, including FREEZE default until ASF bounded resume and disk truth over chat. - Forbidden Topic Guardrails: Blocks recommendations like Cursor AUTO-RUN, new D-modules in briefs, and stealth architecture changes. - Use Case: When drafting an EXTERNAL_CRITIC reply to a founder advisor brief, use this Skill to ensure the response stays read-only, cites factory-now disk truth in the same turn, and respects the advisor/worker/maintainer role split. ## Quick Start Ask the advisor to draft an external critic reply to the latest founder brief while enforcing the four invariants and forbidden topics.

Frequently Asked Questions about advisor-external-critic

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I write an external critic reply for an advisor brief?▼

Draft the reply as read-only critique that upholds the four invariants: FREEZE default until ASF bounded resume, disk truth over chat, one pick with queue equals inbox equals bind, and the advisor/worker/maintainer role split.

What topics are forbidden in advisor critic replies?▼

Forbidden topics include batch drains, 972 chases, new D-modules in briefs, recommending Cursor AUTO-RUN which does not exist, and stealth architecture changes. Replies must stay within read-only critique of packs 2-5, 7-9, and 14.

What are the four invariants every reply must include?▼

The four invariants are: FREEZE default until ASF bounded resume, disk truth beats chat with factory-now in the same turn, one pick where queue equals inbox equals bind, and advisor advises while worker executes and maintainer ships validators.

When should this critic lane not be used?▼

Do not use it for batch drains, implementation work, or architecture changes. It is strictly a critic-only lane for advisor briefs and EXTERNAL_CRITIC replies, with execution delegated to the worker and maintainer roles.

Related Skills

Explore More Product & Management Skills→
daodaoedudaodaoedu

file-bug-issue

Create a reproducible GitHub issue with reproduction steps and environment details.

Official
Intermediate
NorkzYTNorkzYT
2

python-background-jobs

Automates Python background tasks with queues, workers, and Celery examples.

Community
Advanced
EyhenijEyhenij
1

status-report

Formats work status replies as an epic summary paragraph plus a command-backed task table.

Community
Intermediate
jllopisjllopis

telos-purpose-core

Define and govern project changes with four explicit purpose horizons.

Community
Advanced