agent-plan-review-role

Critique AI-generated project plans against defined contracts and scope.

Updated Aug 27, 2026

Search Tags:#project management #decision making #validation #plan review #ai critique

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/AmirTlinov/magray-marketplace --skill agent-plan-review-role

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: agent-plan-review-role
Source: https://github.com/AmirTlinov/magray-marketplace/tree/main/flagship-team/skills/agent-plan-review-role
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/AmirTlinov/magray-marketplace --skill agent-plan-review-role

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a structured framework for reviewing and critiquing AI-generated plans, ensuring they meet specific criteria before execution.

Core Features & Use Cases

Plan Validation: Assesses plans against defined entry contracts and scope.
Critique Protocol: Evaluates each block for subject matter criteria, severity, references, and concrete patches.
Verdict System: Assigns a clear outcome (READY_WITH_PATCHES, NEEDS_REWORK, BLOCKED).
Use Case: Use this Skill to have an AI review a proposed project plan, identifying critical flaws and suggesting necessary revisions before any work begins.

Quick Start

Review the provided plan for the 'user-onboarding' feature.

Frequently Asked Questions about agent-plan-review-role

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I review and critique an AI-generated project plan?▼

You can validate AI-generated plans by assessing them against a defined entry contract and scope, ensuring the proposed project work meets specific criteria before execution begins.

What is the best way to validate AI project plans before execution?▼

The best way to validate AI project plans is using a critique protocol that evaluates each plan block for subject matter criteria, severity, references, and concrete patches to identify critical flaws early.

How does plan block validation work for AI-generated project scopes?▼

Plan block validation works by evaluating each section of an AI-generated plan against specific subject matter criteria, assigning severity levels, and requiring concrete patches to fix identified issues.

Can I use automated decision making to assign a verdict on a proposed project plan?▼

Yes, automated decision making can assign a final verdict to a proposed project plan, categorizing the output as READY_WITH_PATCHES, NEEDS_REWORK, or BLOCKED based on the critique results.

What are the limitations of using AI critique for project management plans?▼

AI critique for project management plans relies on a defined contract and scope; if the entry criteria are vague or incomplete, the severity assessment and concrete patch requirements may lack accuracy.