be-critical

Analyze user ideas with multi-layer adversarial critique to surface blind spots.

Updated Feb 4, 2026

Search Tags:#critical-thinking #decision-analysis #adversarial-prompting #logic-fallacy-detection #assumption-analysis #be-critical

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/pem725/be-critical --skill be-critical

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: be-critical
Source: https://github.com/pem725/be-critical/tree/main
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/pem725/be-critical --skill be-critical

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Be-critical forces Claude Code to challenge user thinking, surface blind spots, and expose flawed reasoning by applying a structured, multi-layer critique.

Core Features & Use Cases

Four activation modes: Stress test my reasoning, Find holes in my plan, Argue both sides, and Full analysis.
Layered critique protocol: assumption analysis, failure projection, confirmation bias detection, multi-perspective critique, and risk synthesis.
Real-world decision support: helps users identify cognitive biases, hidden assumptions, and weak logic before acting on ideas.

Quick Start

Invoke the skill by typing /be-critical and selecting a critique mode, or present a question; the system will apply the chosen analysis sequence automatically.

Frequently Asked Questions about be-critical

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I stress test my reasoning to find logical fallacies?▼

Stress test your reasoning by applying multi-layer adversarial critique to surface blind spots and flawed logic. Selecting the 'Stress test my reasoning' mode triggers assumption analysis, confirmation bias detection, and risk assessment automatically.

What is the best way to find holes in my plan before I execute it?▼

The best way to find holes in your plan is using a structured failure projection framework. The 'Find holes in my plan' mode applies adversarial perspectives and assumption analysis to expose weak logic and identify hidden risks before you act.

How does assumption analysis work for decision support?▼

Assumption analysis works by systematically identifying and challenging hidden premises within your ideas. It applies a fixed framework to detect confirmation bias and surface flawed reasoning, returning a structured critique ready for synthesis.

Can I use be-critical to argue both sides of a decision?▼

Yes, you can use the 'Argue both sides' mode to evaluate a decision from adversarial perspectives. It applies multi-perspective critique to highlight confirmation biases and deliver a structured analysis of opposing viewpoints.

Does critical thinking analysis require external data or dependencies?▼

No external dependencies are required. The critical thinking analysis runs entirely within Claude, applying a fixed framework of adversarial prompting and logic fallacy detection without needing external tools or data sources.

When should I not use automated logic fallacy detection?▼

Avoid automated logic fallacy detection when you need a simple, direct answer rather than a multi-layered critique. The full analysis framework sequences multiple techniques to build on previous layers, which may be excessive for straightforward queries.