comprehensive-review

Merge independent Claude, Codex, and Cursor reviews of Git diffs into one consolidated report.

2|Updated May 6, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/bpcakes/jig-skills --skill comprehensive-review-bpcakes
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: comprehensive-review
Source: https://github.com/bpcakes/jig-skills/tree/main/plugins/jig-review/skills/comprehensive-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/bpcakes/jig-skills --skill comprehensive-review-bpcakes

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes scripts (resource) and references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Single-model code reviews can miss defects or reflect one model's blind spots. This Skill runs multiple independent AI reviewers over the same Git diff, verifies they inspected identical content, and merges their findings into one deduplicated, severity-ordered report. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Multi-model review orchestration: Runs Claude Code and native Codex reviewers in parallel by default, with Cursor Agent (Grok 4.6) as an opt-in third reviewer, each isolated and read-only. - Scope integrity verification: Captures a cryptographic fingerprint of the working-tree or branch diff before and after review, stopping the workflow if the scope drifts or evidence capture is incomplete. - Finding deduplication and attribution: Merges frozen reviewer reports by root cause, keeps the strongest severity, and attributes each finding to the exact reviewers that independently found it. - Optional Beads logging: With --log-to-beads, stores final actionable findings in an existing Beads issue tracker with deterministic deduplication. - Use Case: Before merging a large feature branch, ask for a comprehensive review of your working changes; receive one consolidated report listing critical-to-low findings with file locations, requirement coverage, test gaps, and per-reviewer status. ## Quick Start Ask the agent to use comprehensive-review to review your current working changes with the default Claude and Codex reviewers and report findings without editing code.

Frequently Asked Questions about comprehensive-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I run a multi-model code review on my Git changes?

Invoke the comprehensive-review skill against your working tree or a branch base. It spawns Claude and Codex reviewers in parallel by default, verifies both reviewed the same diff via scope fingerprints, and returns one merged, severity-ordered findings report.

How do I add Cursor or Grok to a Claude and Codex code review?

Pass --all-reviewers or --reviewers claude,codex,cursor to include Cursor Agent with Grok 4.6. You can tune it with --cursor-effort (low through xhigh) and --cursor-speed (standard or fast); it runs read-only in ask mode with sandboxing.

Can the review fix the issues it finds automatically?

The review phase is strictly read-only. Ordinary review-and-fix requests route to the sibling review-fix-loop skill, which owns repairs and bounded re-review; a one-pass repair section applies only when the user explicitly requests a single pass.

What happens if my code changes while the review is running?

The skill captures a scope fingerprint before and after reviewers run. If the fingerprint changes or any reviewer reports a mismatch, the reports are not presented as a same-scope review; the drift is reported and the workflow stops.

How do I exclude files or directories from the review?

Use repeatable --exclude-path flags for exact repository-relative paths, or add permanent entries to a .reviewignore file at the repository root. Globs, negation, and parent-directory segments are rejected; exclusions apply to tracked and untracked content.

Does comprehensive-review work on native Windows?

No. The external Claude and Cursor adapters fail closed on native Windows because descendant process-group termination cannot be guaranteed; run them through WSL. Linux and macOS are supported.