contribution-positioning

Generate a contribution-positioning markdown document with differentiation matrices and reviewer rebuttals.

Updated Mar 27, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended --skill contribution-positioning
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: contribution-positioning
Source: https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended/tree/main/skills/contribution-positioning
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended --skill contribution-positioning

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

Articulates how a research contribution extends beyond prior work, providing a structured way to communicate novelty, framing the narrative for reviewers, and accelerating manuscript writing.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Closest Works Selection: identify 3-5 relevant prior papers and justify their inclusion for positioning.
  • Differentiation Matrix: create a 5-dimension matrix comparing each closest work across Research Question, Method, Models / Data, Key Findings, and Limitation Addressed.
  • Contribution Statement: draft 2-3 candidate statements (method-first, finding-first, problem-first) ready for selection and polishing.
  • Reviewer Objection Anticipation: generate 2-3 sentence rebuttals for each differentiator to address common objections.
  • Related Work Paragraph Drafts: prepare 2-3 sentence paragraphs for each closest work for the related work section.
  • Novelty Staleness Check: optionally compare with novelty-assessment to surface potential updates and warnings.
  • Output: a ready-to-edit contribution-positioning.md document.

Quick Start

Provide novelty-assessment results or a user-described contribution with 3-5 closest works, then run the positioning workflow to generate the full positioning document.

Frequently Asked Questions about contribution-positioning

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I write a differentiation matrix for my research manuscript?

A differentiation matrix compares your 3-5 closest prior works across five dimensions: Research Question, Method, Models/Data, Key Findings, and Limitation Addressed. This structured comparison clarifies how your contribution extends existing work.

How do I position my research contribution against related work?

Positioning your research contribution involves generating multiple contribution-statement variants (method-first, finding-first, problem-first) and drafting 2-3 sentence related-work paragraphs for each closest paper. This articulates your novelty and frames the narrative for reviewers.

How do I anticipate and address reviewer objections in academic writing?

Anticipating reviewer objections requires generating 2-3 sentence rebuttals for each differentiator between your work and prior studies. This prepares you to defend your research contribution by proactively addressing common criticisms regarding method or novelty.

Can I draft contribution statements without prior novelty assessment results?

Yes, you can draft contribution statements without prior novelty assessment by using standalone mode. Provide a user-described contribution and 3-5 user-provided related works manually to generate the full positioning document without pipeline dependencies.

What is the best way to structure a related work section for a manuscript?

The best way to structure a related work section is to prepare 2-3 sentence paragraph drafts for each selected closest work. This positions your contribution by articulating how it extends or differentiates existing work into a ready-to-edit markdown file.

When do I need a novelty staleness check for my contribution positioning?

You need a novelty staleness check when using pipeline mode with prior novelty-assessment results. It optionally compares your current positioning against the assessment to surface potential updates and warnings before finalizing your manuscript writing.