skills.rest
lckx777
lckx777COMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

copy-critic

Validate copy decisions against RMBC/STAND criteria and output structured YAML verdicts.

5|2|Updated Mar 4, 2026
Search Tags:#copywriting#zen-mcp#direct-response#marketing-copy#critical-analysis#validation-framework#ad-validation
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/lckx777/copy-chief-black --skill copy-critic
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: copy-critic
Source: https://github.com/lckx777/copy-chief-black/tree/main/framework/skills/copy-critic
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/lckx777/copy-chief-black --skill copy-critic

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Adversarial validation of copy decisions is complex and error-prone without a repeatable framework. This Skill provides a rigorous, structured critique process to challenge assumptions and improve conversion quality.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Rigorous 5-stage adversarial analysis (Decompose, Verify, Challenge, Synthesize, and Black Validation) to surface hidden risks.
  • Delivers explicit verdicts (STAND, REVISE, ESCALATE) with concrete recommendations for improvement.
  • Integrates with Zen MCP and BLACK Validation to ensure per-deliverable quality before production.
  • Applicable to MUP, MUS, One Belief, hooks, and creatives across marketing campaigns.

Quick Start

Run the copy-critic on a given MUP or MUS to produce a STAND/REVISE/ESCALATE verdict and a concrete improvement plan.

Frequently Asked Questions about copy-critic

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I validate marketing copy decisions before launching a campaign?▼

Adversarial validation decomposes marketing copy through a 5-stage process: Decompose, Verify, Challenge, Synthesize, and Black Validation, ending with a structured YAML output containing a STAND, REVISE, or ESCALATE verdict.

What is adversarial critique in direct-response copywriting?▼

Adversarial critique in direct-response copywriting is a rigorous validation framework that challenges creative assumptions, exposes structural weaknesses, and confirms whether a deliverable satisfies RMBC/STAND criteria before production.

How do I apply a validation framework to MUP and MUS deliverables?▼

Apply the validation framework by running a structured critique across MUP, MUS, One Belief, and hook deliverables to generate explicit verdicts with concrete recommendations and a structured YAML output for per-deliverable quality control.

Does the copy-critic workflow integrate with Zen MCP for ad validation?▼

Yes, the copy-critic workflow integrates with Zen MCP and BLACK Validation to ensure per-deliverable quality, applying adversarial analysis to creatives and outputting structured YAML with confidence levels and recommended actions.

Can I use this critical analysis approach for hooks and creatives across different marketing campaigns?▼

Yes, this critical analysis approach is explicitly applicable to MUP, MUS, One Belief, hooks, and creatives across marketing campaigns, delivering structured verdicts and recommended actions for each specific deliverable type.

Related Skills

Explore More Marketing & Sales Skills→
lckx777lckx777
5

helix-system-agent

Automate end-to-end HELIX briefing documents with RMBC validation and checkpoints.

Community
Advanced
stefan-georgistefan-georgi
13

rmbc-context

Provide shared RMBC methodology context for downstream generative skills.

Community
Advanced
daisyzhang2024daisyzhang2024

python-dev

Validate Python code against Black formatting, PEP 8, and Zen of Python principles.

Community
Advanced
gleesonbgleesonb

direct-response-copy

Write and evaluate direct response marketing copy with frameworks and A/B testing.

Community
Advanced