critic

Name: critic
Availability: InStock
Author: denissvgn

Validate deliverables against requirements by examining architecture, test coverage, and implementation artifacts.

Updated Jan 14, 2026

Search Tags:#requirements traceability #gap analysis #test coverage #architecture validation #quality assessment #critic #artifact review

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/Denissvgn/project-team-ag --skill critic-denissvgn

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critic
Source: https://github.com/Denissvgn/project-team-ag/tree/main/.agent/skills/critic
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Denissvgn/project-team-ag --skill critic-denissvgn

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

The critic validates that deliverables meet the specified requirements by examining architecture, test coverage, and overall quality across the project lifecycle.

Core Features & Use Cases

Architecture Validation: Verify that system design aligns with requirements and architectural decisions.
Test Coverage Review: Assess whether tests cover acceptance criteria, edge cases, and risk areas.
Requirement Traceability: Map artifacts to requirements and identify gaps.
Quality Assessment: Evaluate overall solution quality and readiness for handoff.
Gap Analysis: Identify missing elements and provide actionable remediation steps.

Quick Start

Provide the Analyst requirements, Architect design, QA test reports, and developer implementation to the critic to generate a Validation Report.

Frequently Asked Questions about critic

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I validate that my software architecture meets requirements?▼

Architecture validation involves examining system design to verify alignment with specified requirements and architectural decisions, identifying gaps, and providing actionable remediation recommendations to ensure deliverables meet project goals.

What is requirements traceability and how does gap analysis work?▼

Requirements traceability maps implementation artifacts to original requirements to ensure coverage, while gap analysis identifies missing elements across development cycles and provides actionable remediation steps for quality assessment.

How do I review test coverage for acceptance criteria and edge cases?▼

Test coverage review assesses whether tests adequately cover acceptance criteria, edge cases, and risk areas by examining QA test reports and implementation artifacts to evaluate overall solution quality and readiness for handoff.

What inputs do I need to generate a project validation report?▼

To generate a validation report, provide the Analyst requirements, Architect design, QA test reports, and developer implementation artifacts to the critic for comprehensive traceability, gap analysis, and quality assessment.

Can I use this for quality assessment across the entire development lifecycle?▼

Yes, quality assessment applies across the project lifecycle by validating deliverables, enforcing traceability between requirements and artifacts, and identifying gaps in architecture, test coverage, and overall solution quality.

What is the best way to identify missing elements in implementation artifacts?▼

Gap analysis identifies missing elements by mapping implementation artifacts to requirements and architectural decisions, then generating actionable remediation recommendations to address coverage gaps and quality issues.