critical-review

Critique documents for logical gaps, weak evidence, and bias.

2|3|Updated Nov 9, 2025
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/genesis-agents/GenesisPod --skill critical-review-genesis-agents
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critical-review
Source: https://github.com/genesis-agents/GenesisPod/tree/main/backend/src/modules/ai-app/playground/mission/skills/critical-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/genesis-agents/GenesisPod --skill critical-review-genesis-agents

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Critical Review Protocol helps teams stress-test content by identifying logical gaps, weak evidence, and bias.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Three-pass critique: logical integrity, evidence quality, and bias detection across documents.
  • Structured output: Must fix, Should fix, and Strengths sections for clear remediation.
  • Use cases include academic papers, policy briefs, product specs, and persuasive content that requires rigorous scrutiny.

Quick Start

Provide a structured critique of the target content using the three-pass approach and return the Must fix, Should fix, and Strengths sections.

Frequently Asked Questions about critical-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I identify logical gaps and bias in a policy brief?

Identify logical gaps and bias in a policy brief using a three-pass critique that analyzes logical integrity, evidence quality, and bias detection, returning structured sections for must fix, should fix, and strengths.

What is structured critique and how does it evaluate evidence quality?

Structured critique is a three-pass protocol that stress-tests content by evaluating logical integrity, assessing evidence quality, and detecting bias to produce actionable remediation items for academic papers and persuasive content.

Can I use this critical review approach for academic papers and product specs?

Yes, you can apply critical review to academic papers and product specs, as the protocol is designed to rigorously scrutinize logical gaps, weak evidence, and bias across various document types.

How do I perform a three-pass critique on persuasive content?

Perform a three-pass critique on persuasive content by sequentially evaluating logical integrity, assessing evidence quality, and detecting bias, then outputting categorized must fix, should fix, and strengths sections.

What's the best way to stress-test content for weak evidence before publication?

The best way to stress-test content for weak evidence is applying a structured critique protocol that assesses logical gaps, evidence quality, and bias, delivering prioritized remediation lists for rigorous scrutiny.

When should I not use a structured critique protocol?

Avoid using a structured critique protocol for informal content or quick drafts where deep logical integrity, evidence assessment, and bias detection are not required for final publication readiness.