skills.rest
jatwell93
jatwell93COMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

critique

Evaluate web and mobile interfaces for UX issues and generate a Design Health Score with actionable feedback.

Updated Nov 4, 2025
Search Tags:#design#feedback#heuristics#personas#usability#ux#critique
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/jatwell93/pharmacy-heatmap --skill critique-jatwell93
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critique
Source: https://github.com/jatwell93/pharmacy-heatmap/tree/main/.agents/skills/critique
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/jatwell93/pharmacy-heatmap --skill critique-jatwell93

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Evaluate design from a UX perspective to identify quality gaps and deliver structured, actionable feedback along with a quantitative design health score.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Phase-based critique workflow covering AI slop detection, visual hierarchy, information architecture, cognitive load, emotional journey, discoverability, typography, color, states & edge cases, and microcopy.
  • Generates a Design Health Score using Nielsen-style heuristics and provides an anti-pattern verdict, persona-based red flags, and prioritized recommendations.
  • Supports persona-driven testing (e.g., Alex, Jordan, Sam, Riley, Casey) to surface red flags and tailor feedback to real user types.
  • Outputs a concrete action plan with 3–5 top recommendations and suggested remediation paths to guide design improvements.

Quick Start

Provide a structured critique of the target UI to surface actionable improvements and a prioritized plan for refinement.

Frequently Asked Questions about critique

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I perform a UX critique to identify design quality issues?▼

Perform a UX critique by evaluating visual hierarchy, information architecture, cognitive load, and accessibility to surface actionable feedback. This structured approach outputs a prioritized action plan and quantifies overall design health using heuristic scoring.

What is a Design Health Score and how does heuristic evaluation work?▼

A Design Health Score quantifies UI quality by applying Nielsen-style heuristics to evaluate visual hierarchy, cognitive load, and discoverability. This heuristic evaluation identifies anti-patterns and generates a concrete remediation plan for dashboards, forms, and marketing pages.

Can I use persona-based testing to evaluate web and mobile interface usability?▼

Yes, persona-based testing evaluates web and mobile interface usability by simulating real user types like Alex or Jordan to surface red flags. This persona-driven approach tailors UX critique feedback to specific cognitive load constraints and emotional journeys.

What's the best way to get actionable feedback on visual hierarchy and information architecture?▼

The best way to get actionable feedback on visual hierarchy and information architecture is through a phase-based UX critique. This method analyzes typography, color, states, and microcopy to detect anti-patterns, outputting 3–5 prioritized recommendations for refinement.

Does this UX critique workflow detect AI slop and edge case states in UI design?▼

Yes, this UX critique workflow explicitly detects AI slop and evaluates edge case states alongside core visual hierarchy and cognitive load metrics. It flags persona red flags and anti-patterns to ensure dashboards and marketing pages meet heuristic accessibility standards.

Related Skills

Explore More Design & Creative Skills→
muspelheimmuspelheim
1

roast

Automate multi-perspective UI/UX critique and generate iterative reports with fixes.

Community
Intermediate
nsuberinsuberi

critique

Evaluate interface design quality with Nielsen heuristic scores and prioritized remediation commands.

Community
Advanced
indroputrantoindroputranto
1

critique

Score UX designs against heuristics and detect common anti-patterns.

Community
Advanced
russosalvrussosalv
5

critique

Evaluate web interfaces for UX issues and generate prioritized P0–P3 remediation commands.

Community
Advanced