Generate NYT/New Yorker-style literary critiques of completed manuscripts.
npx skills add https://github.com/PetitChu/holocron --skill critique-petitchu
Please help me install this Agent Skill. Skill: critique Source: https://github.com/PetitChu/holocron/tree/main/skills/critique Command: npx skills add https://github.com/PetitChu/holocron --skill critique-petitchu
It helps you identify craft-level strengths and weaknesses in a completed manuscript, so you can revise with clearer direction rather than guessing.
Run /critique after your manuscript is marked complete to receive a full literary critique in NYT/New Yorker style.
High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.
To receive a NYT-style literary critique, your manuscript must pass completion validation with all chapters marked as drafted or completed. Once validated, the tool reads the full manuscript and generates a professional review highlighting craft-level strengths and weaknesses.
Manuscript review feedback offers three length-controlled formats: long critiques of 1000–1500 words, medium critiques of 400–600 words, and short critiques of 150–250 words. Long and medium modes include detailed craft observations on prose style, structure, and pacing.
No, the writing feedback tool requires a completed manuscript. It performs manuscript-completion validation and declines to process incomplete drafts, ensuring literary critiques are generated only when all chapters are marked as drafted or completed for accurate revision planning.
A professional literary critique is needed before major revisions or between the draft and edit phases. It helps identify craft-level technical observations like characterization, emotional resonance, and thematic coherence, giving you clearer revision direction instead of guessing.
Yes, the critique tool saves writing feedback to a date-stamped output file in the critiques directory. It also automatically updates your progress tracking file, ensuring your novel revision history and manuscript review records are maintained within your project.
The best way to review a specific book within a novel series is to ensure that individual book is marked complete. The tool then reads that full manuscript and generates a focused New Yorker-style critique with craft observations to guide your series revision planning.
howellsCritique completed manuscripts with craft observations on prose, structure, pacing, and characterization.
rinbarpenWrite and review bilingual medical manuscripts with IMRaD structure and statistical reporting.
frankxaiRevise fiction and narrative prose drafts through seven structured passes.
moonseokchoi-krDiagnose root causes of stalled code reviews and propose alternative directions.
