skills.rest
sandrasocial
sandrasocialCOMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

critique

Evaluate web designs for UX problems and generate prioritized P0–P3 feedback reports.

1|Updated Oct 27, 2025
Search Tags:#heuristics#ux#cognitive-load#design-critique#persona-testing#automated-detection
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/sandrasocial/sselfie-9g --skill critique-sandrasocial
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critique
Source: https://github.com/sandrasocial/sselfie-9g/tree/main/.agents/skills/critique
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/sandrasocial/sselfie-9g --skill critique-sandrasocial

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

Provide structured, director-level feedback on designs by combining an independent LLM design review with deterministic automated detection so teams can quickly find high-impact usability, accessibility, and AI-generated "slop" issues and know exactly what to fix first.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Dual independent assessments: Runs an LLM-led design review and a deterministic detector (impeccable) independently to avoid bias and surface different classes of issues.
  • Heuristics & cognitive-load scoring: Produces Nielsen heuristic scores, an 8-point cognitive load assessment, and counts of decision points to quantify UX health.
  • Persona-based and edge-case testing: Walks the product through relevant personas and deliberate stress tests to reveal real-world failure modes.
  • Combined, prioritized report: Synthesizes findings, reconciles false positives, lists P0–P3 issues with why/fix/command mappings, and asks focused follow-up questions.
  • Use Case: Run on a marketing landing page, a settings screen, or a component library to get a prioritized action plan and commands to execute targeted fixes.

Quick Start

Ask critique to review https://example.com/settings and produce a combined LLM and detector-based UX report with Nielsen heuristic scores, cognitive-load results, and prioritized P0–P3 fixes.

Frequently Asked Questions about critique

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I run a UX critique on a live web interface to identify usability issues?▼

To run a UX critique, provide the URL or source markup of your web interface. The tool applies heuristic scoring and cognitive load checks, generating a prioritized P0–P3 action plan to resolve usability issues.

What is heuristic scoring and cognitive load assessment in a design review?▼

Heuristic scoring evaluates designs against Nielsen heuristics, while cognitive load assessment measures mental effort using an 8-point check. Together they quantify UX health and pinpoint decision points increasing user friction.

Can I use automated detection to find AI-generated slop in my component library?▼

Yes, automated detection runs a deterministic scan to identify AI-generated slop in your component library. It operates independently alongside the LLM design review to surface different classes of UX and content issues.

How do I test a settings screen design against specific user personas?▼

To test a settings screen, provide the source markup and specify relevant personas. The tool walks through user journeys and deliberate stress tests to reveal real-world failure modes and edge cases.

Does the design critique require source markup to run deterministic scans?▼

Yes, the design critique requires access to source markup to perform deterministic scans. Optional runtime visualization or CLI tooling can be used to enhance the automated detection process.

Related Skills

Explore More Design & Creative Skills→
russosalvrussosalv
5

critique

Evaluate web interfaces for UX issues and generate prioritized P0–P3 remediation commands.

Community
Advanced
riabtsevriabtsev

audit

Audit front-end code for accessibility, performance, theming, and responsive design issues.

Community
Intermediate
Objective-ArtsObjective-Arts

dedupe-scan

Scan codebases for duplicated code patterns and AI-generated antipatterns.

Official
Intermediate
majiayu000majiayu000
258

product-ux-expert

Apply cognitive psychology, heuristics, and WCAG 2.2 to evaluate UX.

Community
Advanced