Orchestrate structured proponent-skeptic debates to refine proposals into artifacts.
npx skills add https://github.com/sebmartin/ai-workspace-plugin --skill debate-sebmartin
Please help me install this Agent Skill. Skill: debate Source: https://github.com/sebmartin/ai-workspace-plugin/tree/main/skills/debate Command: npx skills add https://github.com/sebmartin/ai-workspace-plugin --skill debate-sebmartin
Many proposals are accepted without rigorous scrutiny, leading to hidden assumptions, blind spots, and weak execution plans. The Debate skill provides a systematic way to challenge and refine ideas before they are committed to action.
Ask the AI to run a debate on the current proposal, specifying the number of rounds you want.
High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.
Pressure-test a proposal by running a structured dialogue between a proponent and a skeptic. This process challenges ideas over multiple rounds to surface hidden assumptions and synthesize a refined execution plan.
Structured debate for proposal refinement is a process that orchestrates alternating turns between a proponent and a skeptic. It systematically challenges ideas within active threads to extract and improve current proposals.
Run a debate on your current thread proposal by asking the AI to start the process and specifying the number of rounds. The skill extracts the idea from the thread context and orchestrates the dialogue to produce a refined artifact.
You can pause the proposal debate process to provide user input through its clarification handling feature. The process pauses automatically when an agent needs accurate information to continue refining the proposal.
Specialist agents are required to run a structured proposal debate for validation purposes. The process allows agents to delegate out to additional specialist agents to ensure rigorous scrutiny during the dialogue rounds.
Limitations of using structured debate include the requirement for access to specialist agents for delegation and the ability to create or update debate artifact files in the thread's artifacts folder to save the synthesized proposal.
yzhao062Ingest NSF solicitation text into a normalized requirements baseline.
sliorExecute one debate phase for a role-specific subagent in a multi-agent design debate.
honerlawAutomate the Minerva propose-ship lifecycle with a 3-agent consensus panel.
tkstangRefine markdown drafts through structured deliberation between two AI peers.
