editorial-critique

Run eight concurrent editorial analyses on Markdown prose and return scored JSON findings.

1|Updated Mar 19, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/lucasmccomb/ccgm --skill editorial-critique
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: editorial-critique
Source: https://github.com/lucasmccomb/ccgm/tree/main/modules/editorial-critique/skills/editorial-critique
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/lucasmccomb/ccgm --skill editorial-critique

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Provides a fast, consistent, multi-angle editorial review for long-form writing so authors and editors can find and prioritize substantive fixes without manual line-by-line passes.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Eight concurrent analysis passes covering prose craft, AI-tells/authenticity, argument architecture, sentence-level quality, grammar & mechanics, data and claims verification, structure/pacing, and conciseness/density.
  • File-aware workflow: selects the most recently modified Markdown post or accepts an explicit path, strips frontmatter, and analyzes the raw prose.
  • Actionable outputs: returns structured JSON findings per pass, a scored scorecard across eight dimensions, and an optional auto-fix mode to apply programmatic edits.
  • Use Cases: editorial teams reviewing blog posts, solo authors polishing essays or reports, and content ops performing rapid, reproducible quality checks.

Quick Start

Run an editorial critique on the most recent post and return a prioritized JSON report with suggested edits.

Frequently Asked Questions about editorial-critique

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I run an automated editorial critique on a markdown blog post?

To run an editorial critique on a markdown blog post, the Skill automatically selects the most recently modified .md file, strips the frontmatter, and analyzes the raw prose across eight concurrent passes to return a prioritized JSON report.

Can I check my essay for AI-detection tells and argument issues at the same time?

Yes, you can check essays for AI-detection tells and argument issues simultaneously through the eight concurrent analytical passes, which specifically evaluate both authenticity and argument architecture alongside prose craft.

What is the best way to get a structured editorial scorecard for long-form prose?

The best way to get a structured editorial scorecard for long-form prose is to use the eight-pass review process, which outputs a scored scorecard across eight dimensions covering craft, authenticity, argument, concision, accuracy, structure, impact, and mechanics.

Does the editorial critique support automatic fixes for grammar and conciseness?

Yes, the editorial critique supports automatic fixes through an optional auto-fix mode that applies programmatic edits to your text after completing the sentence-level, grammar, and conciseness density analysis passes.

Can I review a specific markdown file instead of the most recently modified post?

Yes, you can review a specific markdown file by providing an explicit file path, overriding the default behavior of automatically selecting the most recently modified markdown post for the editorial analysis.

What are the limitations of using an eight-pass editorial review for content operations?

A limitation of this eight-pass editorial review is that it is specifically designed for long-form prose in markdown files, meaning it strips frontmatter and may not apply to non-markdown formats or short-form content types.