inno-idea-eval

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a structured, evidence-grounded evaluation of research ideas using three reviewer personas and a final Area Chair synthesis, ensuring robust assessment before proceeding to downstream development.

Core Features & Use Cases

• Independent persona reviews across five evaluation dimensions: Clarity, Novelty, Validity, Feasibility, and Significance.
• Area Chair meta-review that aggregates scores, resolves disagreements, and issues a final decision.
• Grounded outputs including human-readable critiques and machine-readable logs for integration with ideation and coding workflows.
• Handles standalone evaluation when pipeline artifacts are partially missing, with transparent caveats.
• Outputs include eval_report, eval_scores, eval_decision, and context_variables["idea_evaluation_result"].

Quick Start

Provide a research idea to the Evaluator and run Steps 1 through 4 to obtain a structured Area Chair meta-review and a clear decision.