journal-selection

Ranks five target journals for a manuscript using verified metrics and scope-fit evidence.

Updated Oct 7, 2022
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/tamagusko/linux-cfg --skill journal-selection-tamagusko
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: journal-selection
Source: https://github.com/tamagusko/linux-cfg/tree/main/dotfiles/claude/skills/journal-selection
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/tamagusko/linux-cfg --skill journal-selection-tamagusko

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? Choosing where to submit a manuscript is high-stakes: a wrong target means desk rejection and months lost, and remembered impact factors are often outdated. This Skill produces a defensible, evidence-backed ranking of the five best journals for a specific paper. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Fit-gated ranking: Generates 10-15 candidate journals from the paper's content and citations, gates them on scope fit with named recent papers as evidence, then ranks survivors by verified impact. - Run-time metric verification: Every impact factor, quartile, CiteScore, APC, and review-time figure is verified by live search at run time and stamped with date and source — never recalled from memory. - Honest second opinion: Judges any draft-named target journal, arguing against it when the fit is wrong, and excludes all MDPI titles from recommendations. - Use Case: A researcher finishing a transportation paper asks where to submit; the Skill reads the draft, checks the pipeline map for rejection history, verifies current metrics, and returns a ranked five-journal shortlist with fit evidence and a verdict on the author's intended target. ## Quick Start Ask the assistant to use the journal-selection skill to rank the best target journals for the manuscript in the current project folder.

Frequently Asked Questions about journal-selection

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I choose which journal to submit my paper to?

Gate candidate journals on scope fit first, then rank survivors by impact. This Skill generates 10-15 candidates from your paper's content and citations, verifies each journal's metrics by live search, and returns a ranked top five with fit evidence from recent published papers.

How to find journals that publish papers similar to mine?

The journals your paper cites most are the strongest starting pool, since they publish the conversation you are joining. Fit is confirmed only when the journal's scope statement covers your topic and it has recently published 2-3 concrete papers of the same kind.

Can I trust impact factors I remember or find in old notes?

No. Impact factors change every June and journals migrate quartiles, so this Skill re-verifies every metric by search at run time. Each figure in the output carries the date it was checked and its source.

Does this Skill recommend MDPI journals?

No. MDPI titles are hard-excluded from all recommendations regardless of quartile or impact factor, including as fallbacks or near-misses. Reporting an existing placement at an MDPI venue is allowed, but never recommending one.

What happens if my draft already names a target journal?

The Skill gives the named target an honest second opinion: it confirms it as rank 1, repositions it lower, or argues against it with reasons. Rejection history found in the project folder is treated as the strongest available signal.