Coordinate independent reviewers to assess work for approach flaws and risks.
npx skills add https://github.com/JHostalek/dotclaude --skill judge-jhostalek
Please help me install this Agent Skill. Skill: judge Source: https://github.com/JHostalek/dotclaude/tree/main/skills/judge Command: npx skills add https://github.com/JHostalek/dotclaude --skill judge-jhostalek
This Skill prevents authors from approving their own work without rigorous outside scrutiny, exposing flawed approaches, missed alternatives, and domain-specific risks before acceptance or extension.
Use the judge skill to independently review the most recent substantive work in this conversation and provide a calibrated expert verdict.
High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.
To identify architecture flaws before shipping, coordinate multiple independent reviewers covering domain expertise, pragmatism, and alternative paths. The review evaluates production fitness, proportionality, and overlooked solution paths to expose approach-level flaws.
To review architecture decisions for missed alternatives, apply alternative-path reviewers to evaluate fundamentally different solutions. The synthesis filters findings for evidence, actionability, and trade-off honesty while elevating convergent concerns into a calibrated assessment.
An independent code review panel evaluates software quality by using credibility-based synthesis to filter findings for evidence and calibrated severity. It assesses production fitness and proportionality, producing structured expert, solid, rethink, or red-flag verdicts with prioritized findings.
Yes, expert review applies to architectural decisions, feature designs, and other substantive work, not just code implementations. It provides an independent expert verdict by assessing approach-level flaws, domain-specific risks, and actionable trade-offs before acceptance.
A red-flag assessment is needed during software quality review when independent expert reviewers identify critical approach-level flaws or domain-specific risks that require a complete rethink before acceptance. It indicates the work is not production-fit.
mtthsncValidate architectural decisions and document them in ADRs.
nklischEvaluate a codebase and generate a calibrated multi-dimensional scorecard.
geekjourneyxGenerate code and analyze complex systems with a single prompt.
vinaykumarvkScan codebases for security flaws, quality issues, and accessibility violations.
