Simulate a hostile reviewer to identify critical rejection arguments in research papers.
npx skills add https://github.com/dogekiki/SP-test --skill kill-argument-dogekiki
Please help me install this Agent Skill. Skill: kill-argument Source: https://github.com/dogekiki/SP-test/tree/main/.trae/skills/kill-argument Command: npx skills add https://github.com/dogekiki/SP-test --skill kill-argument-dogekiki
This skill addresses the failure mode where research papers pass standard reviews but contain critical, hidden flaws that would lead to rejection by a senior area chair.
Run the kill-argument skill on the paper directory named research-paper-v1 to generate an adversarial review and adjudication report.
High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.
An adversarial stress-test simulates a hostile reviewer to construct the most damaging rejection argument against a research paper, forcing a second independent adjudication to classify points as answered or unresolved.
Run an adversarial review skill on your paper directory to generate a multi-thread adversarial analysis and adjudication report, validating claims, proofs, and scope against a hostile reviewer simulation.
This adversarial review applies specifically to theory-heavy academic papers requiring pre-submission validation of claims and proofs, rather than general academic writing or empirical studies.
The best way is an adversarial review that constructs a 200-word rejection argument and forces an independent adjudication to classify rejection points as answered, partially answered, or unresolved.
You need mcp__codex__codex to perform the multi-thread adversarial analysis and adjudication, ensuring the review operates without prior context bias.
You should avoid using adversarial review for papers outside theory-heavy domains, as the stress-test specifically targets assumption-vs-claim mismatches and missing proof obligations inherent to theoretical validation.
sjtuytcSimulate adversarial peer review to identify rejection risks in theory papers.
raja21068Generate a strongest rejection argument and adjudicate it against a theory paper's source text.
fredmilhomeAutomate academic manuscript review with single-pass, adversarial, and peer-review modes.
scooter-lacroixFormalize mathematical statements and generate machine-verified proofs using Lean 4.
