skills.rest
Shallow-W
Shallow-WCOMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

kill-argument

Stress-test a paper against an adversarial rejection memo and classify each atomic point.

Updated Apr 21, 2026
Search Tags:#LaTeX#peer review#adversarial review#theory paper#rebuttal preparation#claim-scope audit#critical failure modes
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Shallow-W/llm-wiki --skill kill-argument-shallow-w
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: kill-argument
Source: https://github.com/Shallow-W/llm-wiki/tree/main/.claude/skills/kill-argument
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Shallow-W/llm-wiki --skill kill-argument-shallow-w

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill helps you identify the single most damaging reason a hostile reviewer might give to reject your paper, then checks whether your current text truly neutralizes that critique.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Adversarial attack memo generation: Produces an approximately 200-word rejection paragraph that commits to one strongest failure mode (e.g., theorem validity, scope overclaim, assumption-vs-claim mismatch).
  • Fresh point-by-point adjudication: Decomposes the attack into 3–7 atomic rejection points and classifies each as answered_by_current_text, partially_answered, or still_unresolved using evidence from the current paper files only.
  • Actionable fixes discovery: Produces prioritized top action items (detect-only) to guide rebuttal preparation or the next improvement-loop round.

Quick Start

Use the kill-argument skill on your paper directory (for example, run it with your path in the paper-directory argument) to generate KILL_ARGUMENT.md and KILL_ARGUMENT.json in that same directory.

Frequently Asked Questions about kill-argument

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I stress-test a theory paper before rebuttal preparation?▼

Adversarial stress-testing generates a worst-case rejection memo against your theory paper, decomposes it into atomic critique points, and classifies whether your current LaTeX text resolves each issue. It outputs per-point classifications alongside actionable fixes.

What is an adversarial review for academic papers?▼

An adversarial review identifies the single most damaging failure mode a hostile reviewer might use to reject your paper, such as theorem validity or scope overclaim. It commits to one strongest critique and checks if your current text neutralizes it.

How do I audit my paper for scope overclaims and assumption mismatches?▼

Claim-scope auditing decomposes an adversarial attack into 3-7 atomic rejection points and evaluates each as answered, partially answered, or unresolved. This detects assumption-versus-claim mismatches using only your current paper files.

Can I run adversarial review on LaTeX sources without prior review context?▼

Yes, you can run adversarial review on LaTeX sources without prior review context. The process uses fresh threads to independently evaluate your paper directory and optionally reads the compiled PDF.

When should I use adversarial stress-testing on my paper?▼

Use adversarial stress-testing for theory and scope-sensitive papers during rebuttal preparation or before submission after standard review rounds have stabilized. It should be used once initial revisions are complete.

Related Skills

Explore More Education & Research Skills→
jandan138jandan138

paper-writing

Generate a complete paper directory with LaTeX sources and PDF from a narrative report.

Community
Advanced
sandraschisandraschi
18

mathematical-logic-expert

Solve formal logic problems and validate proofs with LaTeX-friendly formatting.

Community
Advanced
yu13130122297yu13130122297

rebuttal

Convert peer review feedback into a structured rebuttal workflow.

Community
Advanced
wanshuiyinwanshuiyin
123

adversarial-case-builder

Construct an adversarial case memo from evidence ledger and auditor findings.

Community
Advanced