Skills
.Work. You
Rest

light-idea-critique

Community

Rigorous multi-view critique to validate ideas.

Education & Research#multi-perspective#peer-review#literature-search#idea-critique#revision-roadmap#novelty-verification
AuthorLight0305
Version1.0.0
Installs0

System Documentation

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a structured, audit-grade evaluation of research ideas to determine whether they offer genuine novelty, sufficient theoretical depth, and feasible execution, guiding users away from superficial combinations or hollow claims.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Eight-dimension scoring framework aligned with top-tier conference criteria (Originality, Theory Depth, Data, Experiment, Contribution, Delta, Feasibility, Impact).
  • Five-voice critique workflow plus a Devil's Advocate to surface hidden risks and ensure robust reasoning.
  • Blind-then-open review protocol (Phase 1 blind routing, Phase 2 open scoring) with firm detour checks and clear decision gates.
  • Novelty verification using cross-literature checks and structured evidence trails; automatic generation of a Revision Roadmap when revisions are needed.
  • Batch review support for multiple ideas with a reproducible evaluation pipeline.

Quick Start

Input the idea stub (title, domain, keywords) and run the critique workflow to obtain a verdict and a Revision Roadmap.

Dependency Matrix

Required Modules

None required

Components

scripts

💻 Claude Code Installation

Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.

Please help me install this Skill:
Name: light-idea-critique
Download link: https://github.com/Light0305/Light-skills/archive/main.zip#light-idea-critique

Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.
View Source Repository

Agent Skills Search Helper

Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 510,000+ vetted skills library on demand.