loop-plan-evaluator

Validating an execution plan before coding requires checking scope alignment against specifications and confirming DAG validity. This prevents scope creep and rework by catching misordered tasks early.

Execution plan evaluation is a verification process that checks plans against specifications and the current codebase state. It detects work duplication by identifying task overlaps with completed work before implementation begins.

To check DAG validity and dependencies, you analyze the execution plan structure to verify correct task ordering. The evaluator confirms task clarity and readiness to ensure successful multi-task rollouts.

Verifying plan scope against specifications requires plan.md, spec.md, conductor/tracks.md, and metadata.json as inputs. Awareness of the current codebase state is also necessary to output a structured evaluation report.

A multi-perspective review for execution plan validation is needed when handling major tracks. The evaluator invokes a Board of Directors review to provide a comprehensive PASS/FAIL verdict from multiple viewpoints.

Plan evaluation works for both major tracks and regular plans. It applies DAG validation, dependency checking, and task clarity verification to both plan types, outputting a structured PASS/FAIL evaluation report.