makinari-rol-critic

Generate structured critic suggestions from backlog items and EvidenceRecord.

1|Updated May 8, 2025
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Uncodier/API --skill makinari-rol-critic
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: makinari-rol-critic
Source: https://github.com/Uncodier/API/tree/main/src/skills/makinari-rol-critic
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Uncodier/API --skill makinari-rol-critic

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Reads backlog item artefact and evidence to produce structured critic suggestions, enabling teams to improve requirements without overhauling status.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Deterministic critic passes: two bounded iterations to generate recommendations based on acceptance criteria and evidence.
  • Rule-based outputs: each suggestion includes a rule, severity, and fix_hint for concrete improvements.
  • Non-authoritative: never marks items as done; final decision rests with the Judge.

Quick Start

Provide a deterministic critique of a backlog item using its EvidenceRecord and acceptance criteria to generate actionable suggestions.

Frequently Asked Questions about makinari-rol-critic

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I automate critique suggestions for backlog items using acceptance criteria and evidence?

Automate critique suggestions by reading backlog items and their EvidenceRecord to generate actionable outputs. The Skill performs deterministic two-pass iterations to produce structured suggestions based on acceptance criteria and evidence across build, runtime, tests, and scenarios.

What is the output format for automated backlog critique recommendations?

Backlog critique recommendations are output as structured items containing three fields: rule, severity, and fix_hint. These fields provide concrete, actionable improvements without altering the original backlog item status.

How do I generate actionable feedback for backlog items without changing their status?

Generate actionable feedback by running a non-authoritative critique process on backlog items. The Skill produces rule-based suggestions with severity and fix hints while ensuring no changes to item status, leaving the final decision to the Judge.

Does the backlog critique process have a limit on how many passes it runs?

The backlog critique process has a deterministic two-pass limit. It stops after generating recommendations across two bounded iterations based on acceptance criteria and associated evidence, ensuring predictable execution.

Can I use backlog critique automation for items lacking evidence across build, runtime, and tests?

Backlog critique automation applies specifically to items with acceptance criteria and associated evidence across build, runtime, tests, and scenarios. Items lacking this EvidenceRecord structure are outside its processing scope.

Why use a rule-based critique approach over manual backlog review?

A rule-based critique approach provides deterministic, structured suggestions with explicit severity and fix hints, ensuring consistent actionable feedback. It enables teams to improve requirements without overhauling backlog item status.