mc-ai-tell-audit

Audits generated music tracks against fourteen enumerable AI-tell defaults before acceptance.

128|16|Updated Sep 17, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/jtydhr88/music-composition-skills --skill mc-ai-tell-audit-jtydhr88
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: mc-ai-tell-audit
Source: https://github.com/jtydhr88/music-composition-skills/tree/main/plugins/music-composition/skills/mc-ai-tell-audit
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/jtydhr88/music-composition-skills --skill mc-ai-tell-audit-jtydhr88

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? AI music generators fall back to enumerable defaults when a spec does not constrain them, producing tracks that sound synthetic even when the spec was followed faithfully. This Skill provides the final acceptance gate: a fourteen-item checklist of machine fingerprints, a calibrated compliance-rate threshold, and a diagnostic path from symptom to the owning skill. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Fourteen-Item AI-Tell Enumeration: Check each generated track against defaults like 8-bar-multiple sections, monotonically rising energy, grid-locked rhythm, identical chorus repeats, and perfect pitch, with machine-measurable items separated from ear-checked ones. - Two Separate Metrics: Keep compliance rate (did the backend follow the spec) and AI-tell flag count (does the result sound machine-made) as distinct numbers, with zero-point calibration setting the pass threshold at 82 rather than 60. - Remediation Routing: Map each symptom (flat, muddy, mechanical, forgettable) to the specific composition skill responsible for fixing it. - Use Case: A Suno generation comes back with a 95% compliance rate but still sounds like AI. Run the fourteen-item audit, find the energy curve never decreases and the choruses are identical, then route to the arrangement and vocal-direction skills for remediation. ## Quick Start Audit the generated track I just received against the fourteen AI-tell items and tell me whether to accept or reject it.

Frequently Asked Questions about mc-ai-tell-audit

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I check if an AI-generated song sounds too synthetic?▼

Run the fourteen-item AI-tell audit, checking each enumerable default such as 8-bar-multiple sections, monotonically rising energy, grid-locked onsets, and identical chorus repeats. Count the flags individually rather than relying on overall impression.

Why does my AI music sound robotic even when it follows my spec?▼

High compliance rate only means the backend followed the spec, not that the spec itself was well written. If the spec treats rules as conditions to satisfy rather than choices to make, faithful execution produces a high-compliance track that still sounds machine-made.

What is the difference between compliance rate and AI-tell count?▼

Compliance rate measures how faithfully the backend followed the spec fields, while AI-tell count measures how many machine fingerprints the finished audio contains. They diagnose different problems and must never be merged into a single score.

Can AI-tell detection be automated for generated music?▼

Nine of the fourteen items are machine-measurable, including section boundaries, RMS energy curves, chord recognition, and onset grid offset. The vocal items for breath points, ad-libs, and pitch distribution require human listening because thresholds vary per generation model.

Why is the compliance pass threshold 82 instead of 60?▼

Zero-point calibration shows that unrelated, well-produced tracks score 63-66 on the compliance table because any normal song coincidentally satisfies some fields. The calibrated lines are 63-66 for zero point, 70 for passing, and 82 for qualified.

When should fields the backend cannot honor be excluded from scoring?▼

Fields marked honors: none must be excluded from scoring entirely rather than scored as zero. This is a correctness issue, since penalizing the backend for capabilities it lacks distorts the compliance measurement.