novel-review

Reviews novel chapters via the novel-studio pipeline review stage without modifying source text.

116|21|Updated Jul 6, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Xiaoyangy/novel-studio --skill novel-review-xiaoyangy
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: novel-review
Source: https://github.com/Xiaoyangy/novel-studio/tree/main/skills/novel-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Xiaoyangy/novel-studio --skill novel-review-xiaoyangy

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? Long-form fiction projects accumulate quality issues—pacing gaps, broken causal chains, AI-sounding prose—that are hard to diagnose chapter by chapter without accidentally rewriting the original text. This Skill runs the novel-studio pipeline's review stage to produce structured editorial feedback while leaving chapters untouched. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Chapter-by-chapter Editor review: Runs novel-studio --pipeline --stages review over an existing project, writing review opinions to the project's reviews/ directory without modifying chapters/*.md. - Craft-grounded diagnostics: The Editor checks against built-in human-feel craft criteria (scene anomalies, object/trace callbacks, subjective misjudgments, dialogue beats, verifiable causal chains) and writing-technique criteria (goals, obstacles, hooks, event aftermath, transitions), so feedback cites concrete fixes rather than vague style complaints. - Scoped and budgeted runs: Review a chapter range with --from/--to and cap per-chapter Editor time with --budget (default 90s). - Use Case: After generating 30 chapters of a web novel, run the review stage on chapters 3–8 to get a list of structural and continuity issues, then hand the accepted findings to a rewrite pass. ## Quick Start Enter my novel project directory and run the novel-studio pipeline review stage on all chapters, then show me the review opinions written to the reviews folder.

Frequently Asked Questions about novel-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review all chapters of a novel-studio project?

Change into the project root directory and run `novel-studio --pipeline --stages review`. The project path cannot be passed as a positional argument, so you must cd into it first. Review opinions are written to the project's reviews directory.

How do I review only a specific chapter range?

Use the --from and --to flags with the review stage, for example `novel-studio --pipeline --stages review --from 3 --to 8` to review chapters 3 through 8 inclusive. Both default to 0, which means automatic selection.

Does the review stage modify my chapter files?

No. The review stage only produces editorial opinions in the reviews directory and never changes chapters/*.md. To apply changes based on the feedback, use the separate rewrite stage via the novel-rewrite skill.

Why does passing the project path as an argument fail?

The CLI treats positional path arguments as errors because the project root is defined as the current working directory. Run cd into the project directory first, then invoke the pipeline command without a path argument.

How do I control how long the Editor spends per chapter?

Set the --budget flag with a duration, such as `--budget 5m`, to cap each chapter's Editor call. The default hard time budget is 90 seconds per chapter.