openbs-review

Reviews research paper drafts against Prof. Bingsheng He's quality checklists and five-figure rule.

Updated Mar 27, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/megumi-ben/work17 --skill openbs-review-megumi-ben
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: openbs-review
Source: https://github.com/megumi-ben/work17/tree/main/AutoVibeIdea/openbs/skills/openbs-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/megumi-ben/work17 --skill openbs-review-megumi-ben

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? Researchers often submit papers that fail on presentation, structure, and completeness issues that reviewers catch within minutes. This Skill applies Prof. Bingsheng He's (NUS) systematic paper review standards to catch these problems before submission. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Structured Multi-Phase Review: Evaluates papers through a first-impression test, section-by-section checklists (abstract, introduction, related work, motivation, design, experiments), and a 28-point pre-submission detail checklist. - Five-Figure Rule Audit: Verifies the paper contains the five essential figures (motivation, overall comparison, improvement insight, per-technique impact, real-world impact) and flags missing ones. - Notation/Figure/Table Audit: Checks that all notations are defined and all figures and tables are properly referenced and discussed in the text. - Use Case: Before submitting a systems paper to a top conference, paste your draft or provide the file path to receive a structured review with critical issues, minor issues, checklist failures, and an estimated reviewer verdict. ## Quick Start Review my paper draft at paper.pdf using the openbs-review skill and tell me what to fix before submission.

Frequently Asked Questions about openbs-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a research paper before conference submission?

Provide the paper file path or paste the draft text, and the Skill runs a multi-phase review covering structure, section checklists, a 28-point detail checklist, and figure audits. It outputs critical issues, minor issues, and an estimated reviewer verdict.

What is the five-figure rule for systems papers?

The five-figure rule requires a motivation figure, an overall comparison figure, an improvement-insight figure, a per-technique impact figure, and a real-world application impact figure. The Skill checks which are present and suggests content for missing ones.

Can I paste paper text instead of providing a file path?

Yes, the Skill accepts either a file path or pasted text as its argument, as indicated by its argument hint. It reads the content and applies the same review phases in both cases.

What does the 28-point pre-submission checklist cover?

It covers writing quality items such as spell-checking, active voice, sentence and paragraph length, consistent abbreviations and references, figure and table referencing, notation definitions, and grammar details like countable nouns and dangling 'this' references.

Does this review skill work for non-systems research papers?

The checklists are derived from Prof. He's systems paper standards, including the five-figure rule and experimental section ordering. Papers outside systems research may find some criteria, like dataset consistency with top-conference studies, less applicable.