paper-reader-heilmeier

To perform a Heilmeier critique, the skill converts a shared paper into a single structured response covering contribution, method, impact, and risks, enforcing strict per-question attribution. It fuses faithful summary with critique across a fixed seven-question structure.

Yes, you can analyze an arXiv link, arXiv ID, or DOI instead of a PDF upload. The skill works with these common inputs, as well as pasted paper text, to read and evaluate the academic work seamlessly.

Paper analysis separates facts from opinions through trust-preserving boundaries. It enforces paper-only answers for contribution and method, while forcing explicit first-person phrasing for any analytical opinions or critiques.

You can include external citations only when they come from web searches executed during the same response. This citation discipline ensures outside references are fresh, contextual, and directly tied to the paper analysis.

Yes, the structured critique works for long papers by prioritizing key sections. This ensures the Heilmeier-style evaluation captures the core technical method and contribution without getting lost in minor details.

The best way to critically assess an academic work is using a fixed seven-question structure that restricts outside references. This method enforces strict opinion attribution and fresh paper reading for an unbiased evaluation.