paper-review-coach

Perform structured peer-review of academic manuscripts across originality, methodology, results, and writing.

12|2|Updated Apr 21, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/haomingz/kimi-skills --skill paper-review-coach
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: paper-review-coach
Source: https://github.com/haomingz/kimi-skills/tree/main/skills/paper-review-coach
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/haomingz/kimi-skills --skill paper-review-coach

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

提供一个系统化的同行评审框架,帮助用户从原创性、方法论、结果和写作四个维度对论文进行评估,并给出具体的 Major/Minor Revision 建议,以提高投稿质量和评审效率。

Core Features & Use Cases

  • 以原创性、方法论、结果、写作四大维度对论文进行结构化评审,并给出可执行的修改建议。
  • 支持用户在投稿前自评、同行评审练习、以及对稿件的反复修订等场景。
  • 输入包括论文文本、学科领域、目标期刊/会议(可选)以及评审重点等,系统据此定制评审标准。

Quick Start

Submit your manuscript content and target venue, and ask me to perform a full, structured peer-review with actionable revision suggestions.

Frequently Asked Questions about paper-review-coach

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I perform a structured peer review of my academic manuscript before submission?

Structured peer review evaluates academic manuscripts across originality, methodology, results, and writing. You submit your manuscript text, discipline, target venue, and optional focus areas to receive actionable Major or Minor revision suggestions.

What is manuscript evaluation and how does it improve academic writing?

Manuscript evaluation is a systematic assessment of research papers to improve academic writing. It identifies weaknesses in originality and methodology, providing specific revision guidance to increase your chances of acceptance at the target venue.

Can I use peer-review practice for any research discipline and target venue?

Peer-review practice applies to research papers across all disciplines. You must provide clear manuscript text and specify your discipline, while the target venue and focus areas are optional inputs used to tailor the evaluation criteria.

What's the best way to get actionable revision suggestions for methodology and originality?

The best way to get actionable revision suggestions is to request a full structured review covering originality, methodology, results, and writing. Submit your complete manuscript text and target venue to receive specific Major and Minor revision feedback.

What do I need to provide to get research assessment feedback on my paper?

To get research assessment feedback, you need to provide clear manuscript text and your discipline. You can optionally specify the target journal or conference and define focus areas to tailor the manuscript evaluation to your needs.

Are there limitations to automated manuscript evaluation for complex research methodologies?

Automated manuscript evaluation relies entirely on the manuscript text provided. It does not access underlying raw data or run external code, so complex methodology assessments are based solely on the descriptions and results presented in the document.