premise-interrogation

Validate project premises before planning or implementation begins.

Updated Nov 24, 2025
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/ByronWilliamsCPA/.claude --skill premise-interrogation
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: premise-interrogation
Source: https://github.com/ByronWilliamsCPA/.claude/tree/main/.claude/skills/premise-interrogation
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/ByronWilliamsCPA/.claude --skill premise-interrogation

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill solves the common problem of teams wasting engineering time and resources building features, products, or systems that no one actually needs, because the initial premise behind the request was never challenged before planning began.

Core Features & Use Cases

It implements a structured 4-axis interrogation protocol (demand, problem, scope, cost of being wrong) to test if a proposed build is worth pursuing. For example, if a stakeholder requests a new customer dashboard, this skill first confirms who specifically asked for it, what underlying pain point it solves, the smallest test to validate the idea, and the cost of building it unnecessarily. If the premise passes validation, it hands off to downstream skills like brainstorming and feasibility checks; if it fails, it delivers a clear recommendation to stop or adjust the approach.

Quick Start

Use the premise-interrogation skill to challenge the idea of building a new internal reporting tool before drafting any specifications for it.

Frequently Asked Questions about premise-interrogation

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I validate a project premise before starting feature planning?

To validate a project premise before planning, enforce a pre-spec gate that interrogates demand validity, root problem alignment, smallest falsifiable test, and cost of being wrong to prevent wasted engineering work.

What is a pre-spec gate and how does it prevent wasted engineering resources?

A pre-spec gate prevents wasted engineering resources by enforcing a structured interrogation protocol that tests demand validity, problem alignment, falsifiable scope, and cost of being wrong before any planning begins.

How do I test if there is actual demand for a new feature before building it?

You test actual demand for a new feature by applying a 4-axis interrogation protocol that validates who specifically requested it, the underlying pain point, the smallest falsifiable test, and the cost of being wrong.

When should I challenge the scope of a proposed product build?

You should challenge the scope of a proposed product build before any planning or implementation work begins, specifically when a stakeholder proposes building a new feature, product, or system.

What happens if a project premise fails idea validation?

If a project premise fails idea validation, the process delivers a clear recommendation to stop building or adjust the approach, preventing wasted engineering resources on unnecessary features.

Does premise interrogation work for validating internal tool requests?

Yes, premise interrogation works for validating internal tool requests by challenging who specifically asked for it, the underlying pain point it solves, and the cost of building it unnecessarily before drafting specifications.