proposal-critique-refine

Critique proposals through multi-round review with value, feasibility, and risk lenses.

Updated Apr 23, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Ocean326/Agents --skill proposal-critique-refine
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: proposal-critique-refine
Source: https://github.com/Ocean326/Agents/tree/main/skills/global/proposal-critique-refine
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Ocean326/Agents --skill proposal-critique-refine

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Helps teams strengthen an existing proposal by surfacing weaknesses, aligning assumptions with evidence, and guiding targeted improvements through a repeatable critique cycle.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Structured three-round critique with selectable lenses (value, feasibility, risk) and an issue registry to track findings.
  • Guided improvement: targeted repairs, verifications, and a final synthesis for decision-making.
  • Use Case: you have a draft proposal; run critique rounds to clarify goals, remove ambiguities, and lock in actionable next steps.

Quick Start

Provide your existing proposal brief and let this skill run three rounds of critique, improvement, and verification.

Frequently Asked Questions about proposal-critique-refine

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I critique an existing proposal to surface risks and align assumptions with evidence?

To critique an existing proposal, you can run a bounded multi-round review loop applying value, feasibility, and risk lenses to surface weaknesses and align assumptions with evidence. This process maintains an issue register to track findings systematically.

What is a structured multi-round proposal critique and when do I need it?

A structured multi-round proposal critique is a repeatable review cycle that applies targeted lenses to clarify goals and remove ambiguities. You need it when you have a draft proposal requiring targeted improvements and verifications before final synthesis.

Can I use selectable critique lenses to review specific proposal weaknesses like feasibility?

Yes, you can apply selectable critique lenses including value, feasibility, and risk to review specific proposal weaknesses. These lenses guide targeted repairs and verifications across three default rounds of structured improvement.

How do I generate a final memo with residual risks and recommendations from a proposal review?

You generate a final memo by completing the critique rounds and synthesizing the tracked issues. The memo includes round-by-round findings, applied repairs, residual risks, and actionable recommendations for next steps.

What is the best way to track issues and repairs during a proposal critique cycle?

The best way to track issues and repairs during a proposal critique cycle is by maintaining an issue register throughout the multi-round review loop. This register logs findings from applied critique lenses and guides targeted improvements for final synthesis.