refine-critique

Evaluating work package requirements involves scoring them against predefined strategic and functional dimensions using a 0-10 rubric covering value, success criteria, scope, and tier fit to ensure goals are sharp, measurable, and well-defined before design begins.

The minimum requirements score needed to unlock the design phase is 7. This quality gatekeeping threshold prevents ambiguous or poorly defined tasks from entering the pipeline and progressing to architecture work.

Auditing a requirements document requires running a critique evaluation during Phase 2 of the pipeline. It validates goals against the project strategic frame to confirm the work package is ready for the engineering team.

Scoring requirements against strategic and functional dimensions is needed after drafting a work package but before commencing design and architecture phases. This prevents wasted development effort on ambiguous tasks.

If a work package goal does not meet the quality gate score of 7, it fails to unlock the design phase. The requirements must be refined and re-evaluated until they achieve a passing score.

Requirements scoring rubrics operate within the pipeline workflow to validate goals. Proper integration with the pipeline progress tracking system is required to enforce the quality gate and unlock subsequent design phases.