refining-problem

Refine rough research problems into standardized problem.md files with literature mapping.

Updated Jan 23, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/pipemind-com/pipemind-marketplace --skill refining-problem
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: refining-problem
Source: https://github.com/pipemind-com/pipemind-marketplace/tree/main/plugins/scientific-method/skills/refining-problem
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/pipemind-com/pipemind-marketplace --skill refining-problem

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

Convert a rough research idea or informal problem statement into a precise, research-ready formulation and produce a canonical problem.md that captures scope, unknowns, success criteria, constraints, and literature-backed background. The Skill autonomously conducts literature mapping, iteratively refines the problem statement, and determines whether novel research is required based on the mapped prior work.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Autonomous literature-driven refinement: Launches background research agents to synthesize definitions, prior work, and boundary conditions for the problem.
  • Structured problem authoring: Creates and edits a standardized problem.md from a template with sections for scope, key unknowns, success criteria, constraints, and background.
  • Novelty assessment and checkpointing: Iteratively evaluates problem quality, launches targeted research to fill gaps, and sets an immutable novelty requirement informed by literature.

Quick Start

Refine the problem slug dark-matter with initial description "What accounts for missing mass in galaxy rotation?" into a research-ready problem and output the finalized problem.md in a new problem directory.

Frequently Asked Questions about refining-problem

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I refine a rough research idea into a precise problem statement?

To refine a research idea, you provide a problem slug and an initial description, and the Skill autonomously maps literature to iteratively define scope, key unknowns, and success criteria. It outputs a standardized problem.md file capturing the research-ready formulation.

What is the best way to define research scope and key unknowns before starting a literature review?

Defining research scope and key unknowns requires synthesizing prior work and boundary conditions from existing literature. This Skill launches background research agents to extract definitions and constraints, ensuring your problem formulation is structured and literature-backed.

How can I assess the novelty of a scientific research question using prior work?

To assess research question novelty, the Skill synthesizes mapped literature findings and iteratively evaluates problem quality. It sets an immutable novelty requirement based on prior work, determining whether novel research is required for your formulation.

Does this literature-driven problem refinement require predefined references or dependencies?

No predefined references or dependencies are required. You only need to supply a problem slug and an initial informal description; the Skill autonomously conducts background literature mapping and generates the structured problem.md file.

What limitations exist when generating a problem.md file for academic research?

The problem.md generation focuses strictly on academic and technical research questions. It relies on autonomous literature mapping to define constraints and success criteria, meaning output quality depends heavily on the clarity of your initial description.

Can I use autonomous agents to structure constraints and success criteria for technical research?

Yes, autonomous agents can structure constraints and success criteria for technical research. The Skill applies iterative refinement and background task agents to transform informal descriptions into research-ready formulations with standardized scope.