review-draft

Parse a draft and run four critics to generate structured feedback.

11|2|Updated May 29, 2025
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/yulonglin/dotfiles --skill review-draft
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: review-draft
Source: https://github.com/yulonglin/dotfiles/tree/main/claude/local-marketplace/plugins/writing-toolkit/skills/review-draft
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/yulonglin/dotfiles --skill review-draft

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Provides automated, multi-critic feedback to improve drafts by evaluating clarity, structure, factual accuracy, and potential red-team objections.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Runs four critics (clarity, narrative, facts, red-team) in parallel to generate targeted feedback.
  • Suitable for blog posts, academic drafts, policy briefs, and product documents to improve readability and persuasiveness.
  • Outputs a set of actionable recommendations and a consolidated summary for quick iteration.

Quick Start

Provide the draft file path and optional critics to generate feedback.

Frequently Asked Questions about review-draft

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I get structured feedback on a draft document?

To get structured feedback on a draft, provide the file path to a multi-critic processor that evaluates clarity, narrative, factual accuracy, and red-team objections, generating actionable recommendations and a consolidated summary.

What is multi-critic draft review and how does it work?

Multi-critic draft review is an automated process that runs four parallel evaluations on your text—clarity, narrative, facts, and red-team objections—to generate targeted, structured feedback notes for improving readability and persuasiveness.

Can I use automated draft review for academic papers and policy briefs?

Yes, you can use automated draft review for academic papers, policy briefs, blog posts, and product documents, applying multi-critic feedback to improve readability and persuasiveness across these various applicable contexts.

How do I generate red-team objections for a draft?

To generate red-team objections for a draft, run the red-team critic component on your provided file path, which will output targeted feedback notes under a dedicated feedback directory alongside other critic evaluations.

Does draft feedback require any specific dependencies?

No specific dependencies are required to run the draft feedback process, but you must provide a valid draft file path so the system can parse the text and output the per-critic notes and summary in a feedback directory.

What is the best way to consolidate multiple critic reviews for a draft?

The best way to consolidate multiple critic reviews is to run four parallel critics on a draft, which automatically outputs a consolidated summary alongside per-critic notes in a feedback directory for quick iteration.