review-implementation

Reviews code against markdown specs and maps requirements to file-line evidence.

209|27|Updated Apr 19, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/golbin/agent-skills --skill review-implementation-golbin
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: review-implementation
Source: https://github.com/golbin/agent-skills/tree/main/skills/review-implementation
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/golbin/agent-skills --skill review-implementation-golbin

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

It helps you confirm that an implementation actually satisfies provided markdown requirements and specs, and it can apply focused fixes when gaps or overbuilt work are found.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Requirements traceability review: maps each stated requirement to code evidence and clearly labels satisfied, partial, missing, conflicting, overbuilt, or deferred items.
  • Multi-pass correctness and risk audit: checks coverage, correctness, integration fit, simplicity, cleanup, security/privacy, performance, validation approach, and documentation/operability needs.
  • Targeted fix mode: applies minimal, reversible code changes to bring behavior back in line with the docs without adding unjustified features.

Quick Start

Ask the AI to review your implementation by providing the relevant .md spec files and the codebase context, and request either review-only results or focused fixes to match the documentation.

Frequently Asked Questions about review-implementation

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I verify code compliance against markdown requirements and PRDs?

You can verify code against markdown specs by extracting acceptance criteria from documentation and mapping them to concrete file and line evidence. This requirements traceability process classifies items as satisfied, partial, missing, or conflicting to ensure complete spec compliance.

What is requirements traceability and how does gap analysis work for implementation verification?

Requirements traceability maps each stated spec criterion to concrete code evidence. Gap analysis works by identifying missing, partial, or conflicting implementations during this mapping process, ensuring your codebase fully satisfies the provided documentation without unjustified overbuilt features.

Can I automatically fix code gaps found during a spec compliance audit?

Yes, you can automatically fix code gaps using the targeted fix mode. It applies minimal, reversible code changes to align behavior with your markdown documentation, correcting bug risks and divergences without adding unjustified features beyond the spec scope.

Does this review process assess security, privacy, and performance alongside coverage?

Yes, the review process assesses security, privacy, and performance alongside coverage. It performs a multi-pass audit checking correctness, integration fit, simplicity, cleanup, and validation approach to provide comprehensive, evidence-backed reporting on your implementation.

How do I run an audit of phase completion for my software implementation?

To run an audit of phase completion, provide your phase docs and codebase context to the AI. The Skill maps the documentation's acceptance criteria to code evidence, verifying correctness, integration fit, and requirement coverage to validate that the phase is fully implemented.

When should I not use targeted fixes for code divergence?

You should not use targeted fixes when the divergence requires significant refactoring beyond minimal changes. The fix mode applies only minimal, reversible adjustments to match documentation, avoiding the addition of unjustified features or complex architectural changes not specified in the PRD.