review-paper

To get a peer review for an economics manuscript, submit your paper file in tex, pdf, or qmd format. The skill evaluates the argument structure, econometric specifications, and literature positioning to generate a structured referee report.

You can automate referee report generation by providing a manuscript file path or using a filename under master_supporting_docs. The system produces 3-5 referee objections and saves the final review to a markdown file.

The best way to critique identification strategy is to evaluate causal claims, assumptions, threats to identification, and robustness checks. This skill applies these econometric criteria to your manuscript and highlights methodological weaknesses.

Yes, the manuscript review process works directly with LaTeX (.tex), PDF, and Quarto (.qmd) files. You simply provide the file path, and it analyzes the document from introduction to conclusions.

To check citation completeness and literature positioning, the review assesses coverage of prior work, accurate characterization of sources, and consistent notation. It identifies gaps in how your paper positions itself within the existing literature.

The structured paper review report is saved as a markdown file located at quality_reports/paper_review_[sanitized_name].md. This provides a clear, publishable structure containing the generated referee objections and overall evaluation.