review3-confirm

What problem does it solve?

This Skill resolves disagreements from an earlier reviewer cycle by forcing every defender reply into a final, verifiable consensus state or a user arbitration outcome, while requiring explicit clarifications for any items labeled as needing further input.

Core Features & Use Cases

• Consensus confirmation for each Review-Reply pair: Converts each Rn item into one of the allowed end states: 已共识·实施 / 已共识·延后 / 已共识·否决 / 需补充回复.
• Anti-passing guardrails: Enforces stage integrity, forbids “waiting to decide” outcomes like legacy formats, and prevents leaving disputes unresolved.
• Clarification-first branch: When items are marked as待澄清, it outputs澄清内容 for Defender to address, then requires rerunning review2-reply before confirmation again.
• User arbitration closure for real disputes: When reviewer cannot decide unilaterally, it initiates an on-the-spot user decision loop and records the裁决记录.

Quick Start

Use the review3-confirm skill with the document path to confirm the Defender’s replies item-by-item and either finalize consensus or produce澄清/仲裁 outcomes as required.