reviewing-scale-prior-art-survey

Hand the reviewer one artifact of one kind — keyword-map, search, extract, or synthesis — after it has passed its deterministic gate. The reviewer reads the matching condition group in references/conditions.md, checks the staged evidence, and returns findings plus one verdict.

It judges faithfulness the gate cannot: whether the declared band matches the handed scope, whether measured values are the source's own numbers, whether configuration_stated and primary_dimension are accurate, and whether absences carry receipts. It never re-runs schema or count checks.

Run the deterministic gate first; it validates schema, enums, and counts and returns early on failure. Run this review only after the gate passes, since the conditions deliberately avoid restating anything the gate already decides.

Any condition whose required evidence was not staged is recorded as unjudgeable and stated as such in the output. The reviewer never guesses at missing evidence and never marks an unverifiable condition as passed.

It reviews one artifact of one kind per run and does not judge prose quality or score the underlying source. It also cannot decide anything the deterministic gate owns, such as field presence, enum membership, or count reconciliation.