reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey

Reviews visual prior-art survey artifacts against 40 numbered acceptance conditions and emits a verdict.

1|1|Updated May 24, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/bm629/agent-skills --skill reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey-bm629
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey
Source: https://github.com/bm629/agent-skills/tree/main/skills/reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/bm629/agent-skills --skill reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey-bm629

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Visual prior-art surveys of UI conventions are easy to write and hard to trust: a tidy-looking artifact can hide unchecked citations, conflated zero results, or padded coverage. This Skill acts as an independent acceptance gate that judges a finished survey artifact against a single authoritative bar before it is approved. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Condition-based review: Walks 40 numbered conditions covering the vocabulary map, per-angle search output, extract records, and the convention register, quoting the exact artifact text that fails each one. - Citation spot-checking: Verifies that every cited corpus actually contains the convention claimed, catching plausible-looking but unsupported records. - Proportionality filter: Approves thin-but-honest results for narrow UIs and revises only on named, unrecorded gaps, preventing padding. - Use Case: After producing a UI-pattern vocabulary map and per-angle search output for a new product, run this reviewer to receive exactly one verdict line — VERDICT: approve or VERDICT: revise — with grounded findings naming their condition numbers. ## Quick Start Use reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey to judge the vocabulary map and search output in my survey folder and give me the verdict with findings.

Frequently Asked Questions about reviewing-visual-prior-art-survey

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a UI prior-art survey before accepting it?

Run this Skill on the finished artifact. It walks 40 numbered conditions from references/conditions.md, quotes the failing text for each finding, and emits exactly one verdict line: VERDICT: approve or VERDICT: revise.

What artifacts does this visual survey reviewer accept as input?

It judges the wave-1 artifacts of a visual prior-art survey: the UI-pattern vocabulary map and the per-angle search output, plus wave-2 extract records and the convention register. It does not review market, user-research, code, or regulatory surveys.

Does the reviewer fix or rewrite the artifact it rejects?

No. It never authors or repairs content. Each finding names the failed condition and quotes the failing text; the producing skill closes the gap in a revise round.

Why did the reviewer approve a survey with zero search results?

A recorded zero with a real query is a receipt proving the search ran, not a defect. Under condition C27, thin-but-honest output is correct for a narrow UI; only unrecorded gaps trigger a revise verdict.

When should I not use this reviewing skill?

Do not use it to author survey artifacts, to review non-visual surveys such as market or regulatory research, or to re-litigate the angle taxonomy, which is owned by the source registry.