scholar-evaluation

Evaluate scholarly work across defined quality dimensions using the ScholarEval framework.

Updated Feb 3, 2026

Search Tags:#peer review #research evaluation #evaluation framework #research quality #academic assessment #scholarly writing

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/loganylchen/skills --skill scholar-evaluation-loganylchen

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: scholar-evaluation
Source: https://github.com/loganylchen/skills/tree/main/scholar-evaluation
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/loganylchen/skills --skill scholar-evaluation-loganylchen

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes scripts (resource) and references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a structured framework for systematically evaluating scholarly and research work, ensuring comprehensive analysis across multiple quality dimensions.

Core Features & Use Cases

Dimension-Based Evaluation: Assesses research across key areas like problem formulation, methodology, writing, and citations.
Scoring and Feedback: Provides both qualitative assessments and quantitative scores, along with actionable feedback.
Use Case: A researcher can use this Skill to get a detailed, objective evaluation of a draft research paper before submission, identifying strengths and areas for improvement based on established academic criteria.

Quick Start

Use the scholar-evaluation skill to evaluate the attached research paper draft using the full ScholarEval framework.

Frequently Asked Questions about scholar-evaluation

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I evaluate a research paper draft before submission?▼

An academic assessment framework systematically evaluates research quality by scoring problem formulation, methodology, writing, and citations, providing both qualitative feedback and quantitative aggregate scores for scholarly work.

What is the best way to systematically assess academic writing and methodology?▼

Systematically assessing academic writing and methodology involves applying defined evaluation criteria across key research dimensions, calculating aggregate scores, and generating actionable feedback for literature reviews or proposals.

Can I calculate quantitative scores for a literature review using an evaluation framework?▼

Yes, you can calculate quantitative scores for a literature review by executing dedicated scoring scripts that aggregate dimensional assessments of problem formulation, methodology, writing, and citations into a final score.

Does peer review evaluation cover problem formulation and citations?▼

Yes, peer review evaluation covers problem formulation and citations by systematically analyzing these defined dimensions within academic papers to provide comprehensive research quality assessments and actionable improvement feedback.

How do I get objective feedback on my research proposal?▼

To get objective feedback on a research proposal, evaluate the document against established scholarly criteria across methodology and problem formulation dimensions, yielding qualitative assessments and quantitative scores.