team-idea-eval

Scores project ideas against a six-axis team rubric and three member personas.

Updated Jul 4, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/100Thieves-team/plady-expert-skills --skill team-idea-eval-100thieves-team
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: team-idea-eval
Source: https://github.com/100Thieves-team/plady-expert-skills/tree/main/.claude/skills/team-idea-eval
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/100Thieves-team/plady-expert-skills --skill team-idea-eval-100thieves-team

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Teams often evaluate new project ideas through scattered opinions and gut feelings, repeating past pivot mistakes. This Skill turns a team's meeting-derived evaluation criteria and member personas into a reproducible scoring process for idea selection. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Six-axis weighted scoring: Rates each idea on domain familiarity, real-user retention, two-week deployability, three-member tech alignment, technical depth, and value clarity, with a non-negotiable gate that fails ideas scoring 1 on any critical axis. - Persona-based scoring: Scores ideas from three team member personas (backend, frontend, infrastructure) using each persona's five evaluation questions, and flags ideas with high score variance as risky. - Structured comparison output: Produces three tables (team criteria, persona scores, final ranking with recommendations and improvement actions) in Korean. - Use Case: Before a planning meeting, submit two or three candidate project ideas and receive a ranked comparison showing which idea fits the team, which member might disengage, and how to strengthen the leading candidate. ## Quick Start Ask the assistant to evaluate your project idea with the team-idea-eval skill, for example by saying "evaluate these two project ideas against our team criteria and personas."

Frequently Asked Questions about team-idea-eval

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I evaluate project ideas against team criteria?

Provide one or more ideas and the skill scores each on six weighted axes: domain familiarity, real-user retention, two-week deployability, team tech alignment, technical depth, and value clarity. It outputs a weighted total out of 5.0 plus a pass/fail non-negotiable gate check.

How does persona-based idea scoring work?

Each idea is scored 1-5 from three team member personas using the five evaluation questions defined in each persona card. The skill computes the average and standard deviation, flagging ideas with variance of 1.5 or higher as ones only one member is excited about.

What inputs does the team idea evaluation need?

It needs at least one idea described in a sentence or paragraph, and optionally paths to meeting notes or planning documents to cite as evidence. If no idea is given, it asks the user for candidates before scoring.

Can I add a new team member to the evaluation?

Yes. Add a new persona card file under references/personas following the same nine-section format, then add one row for that persona in the criteria file. The skill logic itself does not change.

What happens when an idea fails the non-negotiable gate?

If an idea scores 1 on any of the four gate axes (domain familiarity, real users, two-week deployment, or three-member alignment), it is marked as gate-failed regardless of its weighted total, because those represent explicit team deal-breakers.