What problem does it solve?
Structured critical reasoning is often ad hoc and inconsistent. This Skill provides a repeatable framework to stress-test ideas, plans, or proposals by applying defined reasoning modes, steelmanning the argument, and delivering actionable synthesis.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Steelman thesis: Restate the user's position in its strongest form before challenging it.
- Mode-driven critique: Let the user select a challenge mode and load guided references.
- Reference-guided reasoning: Load topic-specific guides to ground the critique in evidence.
- 3-5 strongest challenges: Present focused, high-impact objections with mitigations.
- Synthesis & next steps: Integrate insights into a refined position and clear recommendations.
- Second-pass option: Re-run with a different mode for deeper validation.
- Use cases include risk assessment, design audits, decision reviews, and strategy evaluation.
Quick Start
Begin the session by selecting a challenge mode and confirming the steelman thesis to initiate the critique.