theory-fit-assessment

Assess candidate theories against research questions across five fit dimensions.

265|23|Updated Feb 7, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/yipng05-max/-skills --skill theory-fit-assessment-yipng05-max
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: theory-fit-assessment
Source: https://github.com/yipng05-max/-skills/tree/main/theory-fit-assessment
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/yipng05-max/-skills --skill theory-fit-assessment-yipng05-max

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill prevents “label-style” theory use by helping researchers systematically assess whether a chosen theory truly matches their specific research question, including mechanism alignment, epistemological compatibility, analysis level fit, empirical operability, and China-context transferability.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Theory-to-Question Matching Across Key Dimensions: Evaluates problem-domain fit, mechanism fit, epistemological compatibility, level-of-analysis fit, empirical operationalizability, and (for China studies) context transferability.
  • Decision Support for Theory Selection: Helps users compare multiple candidate theories and make a defensible “use / adapt / avoid” decision.
  • Misuse Prevention: Detects common contradictions such as mixing incompatible epistemologies or using theories whose core mechanisms cannot be evidenced by the planned data.

Quick Start

Ask an AI to run theory-fit-assessment by evaluating whether the “selected theory” fits your “research question,” including what mechanisms you think it explains and what evidence you can realistically collect.

Frequently Asked Questions about theory-fit-assessment

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I assess whether a candidate theory fits my research question?

Compare candidate theories by testing mechanism correspondence and epistemological compatibility against your research question, yielding a dimension-by-dimension fit rating and a use, adapt, or avoid decision rationale.

What is theory fit assessment in qualitative social science research design?

Theory fit assessment verifies mechanism alignment, epistemological compatibility, and empirical operationalizability between a candidate theory and a research question, preventing label-style theory application in social-science workflows.

How to compare Bourdieu vs Foucault for a specific research question?

Generate a cross-theory comparison by rating each theory's mechanism correspondence, epistemological compatibility, and level-of-analysis fit against your research question, yielding a defensible use, adapt, or avoid recommendation.

Can I use a theory if its core mechanisms cannot be evidenced by my planned data?

Avoid theories whose core mechanisms cannot be evidenced by your planned data; theory fit assessment detects mismatches between planned empirical evidence and a theory's explanatory mechanisms to prevent misuse.

Does theory fit assessment work for China context social science research?

Yes, theory fit assessment evaluates China-context transferability as a distinct dimension, verifying that candidate theory mechanisms and epistemologies remain appropriate for China-specific social science research questions.

When should I not use a candidate theory for my research design?

Avoid a candidate theory when assessment reveals incompatible epistemologies, mismatched levels of analysis, or core mechanisms that cannot be operationalized using evidence you can realistically collect for your research design.