What problem does it solve?
Automated checks, review agents, and referee simulations are often trusted without evidence that they can actually detect the failures they claim to catch. This Skill grades the grader: it seeds known defects into a copy of a real artifact, runs the checker blind, and records recall and false-positive rates in a qualification ledger so a green light means something.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Seeded-defect qualification: Plants defects from a categorized defect library (analysis code, manuscripts, replication packages, slides, infrastructure) into copies of artifacts, plus a mandatory clean control.
- Blind scoring protocol: Runs the checker in a fresh context per variant and scores recall, false-positive rate, localization, and a baseline delta against a simpler alternative like grep.
- Qualification ledger: Appends PASS, FAIL, or BLOCKED verdicts to quality_reports/qualification/LEDGER.md so every trusted check has a recorded measurement.
- Use Case: Before relying on a referee simulation for a paper submission, run the skill to prove the reviewer detects planted defects such as a text coefficient that no longer matches its table.
Quick Start
Ask the AI to vaccinate a specific checker against a specific artifact, for example: qualify whether scripts/check-model-versions.sh can detect a superseded model claim seeded into README.md.