Verified:GitHub

writing-mentor

Validate data and provide two-tier feedback on written work.

Updated Jan 16, 2026

Search Tags:#data validation #academic writing #writing feedback #consistency checking #pedagogical feedback #analytical review

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/Black-JL/writing-mentor-framework --skill writing-mentor

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: writing-mentor
Source: https://github.com/Black-JL/writing-mentor-framework/tree/main/skills/feedback
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Black-JL/writing-mentor-framework --skill writing-mentor

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes scripts (resource) and references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides structured, rigorous feedback on written work, going beyond surface-level review to validate data, check consistency, and deliver pedagogical guidance.

Core Features & Use Cases

Data Validation: Checks charts against formulas, calculations against claims, and data sources against external APIs.
Two-Tier Feedback: Delivers detailed technical notes for reviewers and teaching-focused guidance for writers.
Assumption Auditing: Verifies economic and statistical assumptions against course principles or general practice.
Use Case: A student submits an analytical paper with accompanying spreadsheets and charts. The Writing Mentor Skill thoroughly audits the data pipeline, identifies inconsistencies, and provides actionable feedback to both the student and the instructor.

Quick Start

Use the writing-mentor skill to review the attached document and spreadsheet.

Frequently Asked Questions about writing-mentor

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I get structured academic writing feedback on data and assumptions?▼

Structured academic writing feedback validates data pipelines, audits statistical assumptions, and checks internal consistency to deliver pedagogical guidance. This Skill thoroughly reviews documents and spreadsheets to identify inconsistencies and provide actionable teaching notes for writers and technical notes for reviewers.

Can writing feedback check calculations against claims and external data sources?▼

Yes, writing feedback can check calculations against claims and external data sources through rigorous data validation. The Skill verifies charts against formulas and validates data sources against external APIs to ensure intellectual rigor and internal consistency across your analytical review.

What is the best way to audit economic and statistical assumptions in an analytical paper?▼

The best way to audit economic and statistical assumptions is through systematic evaluation checklists that verify them against course principles. This Skill performs assumption auditing to check whether your analytical review aligns with general practice and pedagogical requirements.

Does this feedback tool provide separate guidance for students and instructors?▼

Yes, this feedback tool provides separate guidance for students and instructors through two-tier feedback. It delivers detailed technical notes for reviewers and teaching-focused pedagogical guidance for writers, ensuring both audiences receive relevant analytical review insights.

How do I review an analytical paper with accompanying spreadsheets and charts?▼

To review an analytical paper with spreadsheets and charts, use this Skill to thoroughly audit the data pipeline. It provides structured feedback by validating data, checking consistency between charts and formulas, and identifying inconsistencies across the submitted documents.

Are there limitations to consistency checking for pedagogical writing feedback?▼

Consistency checking for pedagogical writing feedback relies on the provided documents and data sources. While it validates data against external APIs and course principles, complex analytical review assumptions may require manual verification if the underlying data pipeline is incomplete or inaccessible.