alterlab-paper-reviewer

What problem does it solve?

This Skill enables editors and researchers to simulate comprehensive, phase-based peer reviews of scholarly manuscripts using a standardized, multi-agent workflow (EIC + 3 peer reviewers + Devil's Advocate), producing structured feedback and a clear revision roadmap.

Core Features & Use Cases

• Phase-driven reviewer configuration: automatically assembles five distinct reviewer personas (EIC, Methodology, Domain, Perspective, Devil's Advocate) and presents configurable identities.
• Parallel Phase 1 reviews: each reviewer produces independent reports without cross-talk, ensuring diverse critique.
• Editorial synthesis: consolidates reports, identifies consensus/disagreements, and generates an Editorial Decision plus a prioritized Revision Roadmap.
• Re-review support: verifies revision quality against the ROADMAP and outputs residual issues and updated decision.
• Output formats: standardized templates for reviewer reports, revision responses, and decision letters.

Quick Start

Provide a manuscript and specify any domain constraints; the system will run Phase 0 field analysis, Phase 1 parallel reviews by 5 agents, Phase 2 editorial synthesis, and return a full revision roadmap.