critic-pass

Validate drafts against task prompts for logical and factual errors.

Updated May 30, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools --skill critic-pass
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critic-pass
Source: https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools/tree/main/skills/critic-pass
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools --skill critic-pass

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes scripts (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a low-cost, high-ROI way to verify high-stakes deep-reasoning drafts, helping prevent costly mistakes before they reach the final stage.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Cheap Verification Loop: Conducts a cost-effective critic pass over draft outputs before they are committed.
  • Deep-Reasoning Drafts: Checks drafts for unsupported claims, logical gaps, missed constraints, and factual errors.
  • Use Case: Before committing architecture, migrations, or clinical analysis drafts, run the critic pass to catch potential issues early and reduce the risk of costly mistakes.

Quick Start

Use the critic-pass skill to check a draft by running: node critic.mjs prompt --task "<task>" --draft "<draft>"

Frequently Asked Questions about critic-pass

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I verify a deep-reasoning draft for logical and factual errors before committing?

To verify a deep-reasoning draft for logical and factual errors, you can run a critic pass using a script like `node critic.mjs` with your task and draft inputs to validate against unsupported claims and missed constraints.

What is the best way to check architectural proposals for missed constraints?

Checking architectural proposals for missed constraints is best done using a critic pass that operates in report-mode, logging unsupported claims and logical gaps without blocking the commit of your high-stakes output.

Does the critic pass script block the commit of high-stakes outputs?

The critic pass script does not block the commit of high-stakes outputs; it operates in report-mode, logging factual verification findings and logical errors so you can review potential issues early.

Do I need a specific model to run factual verification on drafts?

Running factual verification on drafts requires a Sonnet or llm_azure model to parse results and conduct the deep-reasoning checks needed to validate your task prompt against the draft.

When should I use a draft verification loop for my analysis drafts?

A draft verification loop should be used for high-stakes deep-reasoning tasks like financial analyses or migrations, providing a low-cost way to catch logical gaps and factual errors before final commitment.

Can I use this critic pass for clinical analysis draft verification?

You can use this critic pass for clinical analysis draft verification, as it is specifically intended for deep-reasoning components to identify unsupported claims and factual errors in high-stakes outputs.