follow-up-review

Review updated pull requests by evaluating only commits since the last reviewed SHA.

413|31|Updated Mar 16, 2025
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/gittower/git-flow-next --skill follow-up-review
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: follow-up-review
Source: https://github.com/gittower/git-flow-next/tree/main/.claude/skills/follow-up-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/gittower/git-flow-next --skill follow-up-review

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill helps reviewers assess an incoming pull request after the author has responded to prior feedback, so they can focus only on what changed since the last review instead of re-checking the entire PR.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Round-aware review: Reconstructs the previous review’s requests and ties them to the latest author replies.
  • Delta-only evaluation: Reviews only the commits added since the last reviewed SHA, reducing noise and avoiding repeated feedback.
  • Decision-ready output: Produces a structured follow-up draft with resolved, still-open, partially addressed, and new findings.
  • Use case: A maintainer receives an updated PR after asking for changes and wants a concise, evidence-backed follow-up review before posting.

Quick Start

Review PR 42 with the follow-up-review skill and prepare the delta-only assessment for the latest round.

Frequently Asked Questions about follow-up-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a pull request delta after the author responds to feedback?

To review a pull request delta, evaluate only the commits added since the last reviewed SHA and check author reply threads to verify if prior maintainer requests were resolved. This delta-only approach avoids re-checking the entire PR and prevents repeating previous feedback.

What is a follow-up code review and when do I need it?

A follow-up code review is an assessment of an updated pull request after an author addresses prior maintainer feedback. You need it when a PR receives new commits following requested changes, allowing you to focus strictly on the delta rather than re-reviewing untouched code.

How do I check if prior code review requests were resolved in a new PR commit?

To check if prior code review requests were resolved, reconstruct the previous review's asks, map them to the latest author replies, and evaluate the delta since the last reviewed commit. This produces a decision-ready draft categorizing items as resolved, still-open, or partially addressed.

Can I prepare a structured GitHub pull request follow-up review before posting?

Yes, you can prepare a structured GitHub pull request follow-up review by reconstructing prior asks and evaluating the delta. This generates a verdict-ready draft with evidence for each prior item, categorizing findings into resolved, still-open, partially addressed, and new issues.

Does delta review work for multiple rounds of maintainer feedback on the same PR?

Delta review works for follow-up rounds by reconstructing previous requests and tying them to the latest author replies. It evaluates only the delta since the last reviewed commit, making it suitable for ongoing maintainer interactions across multiple update cycles.

What is the best way to avoid repeating code review feedback on updated pull requests?

The best way to avoid repeating code review feedback is to perform a delta-only evaluation. By reconstructing prior asks and checking reply threads, you ensure only new commits are assessed, reducing noise and preventing duplicate comments on unchanged code.