harvard-strategist

Critique research questions and paper drafts for unit of analysis and case relevance.

Updated Apr 10, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/phdemotions/faculty-meeting --skill harvard-strategist
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: harvard-strategist
Source: https://github.com/phdemotions/faculty-meeting/tree/main/skills/schools/harvard-strategist
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/phdemotions/faculty-meeting --skill harvard-strategist

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This advisor helps researchers sharpen the strategic framing of management and strategy research by locating the unit of analysis, demanding empirical cases, and ensuring managerial relevance so that theoretical claims are grounded and practically meaningful.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Case-first critique: Demands concrete empirical settings and interrogates whether the proposed case makes the research tractable and interesting.
  • Unit-of-analysis clarity: Identifies and tests whether the study consistently treats the firm, business unit, industry, or individual as its analytic focus.
  • Managerial relevance: Connects theoretical findings to decisions managers might actually make and highlights practical implications.
  • Use Case: Refine a dissertation research question to specify the unit of analysis, propose tractable case settings, and generate targeted empirical tests for competitive advantage claims.

Quick Start

Ask the advisor a concise research question or paste a manuscript excerpt and request a structured Assessment, Key Questions, and Recommendation in the Harvard tradition.

Frequently Asked Questions about harvard-strategist

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I refine a management research question to ensure my unit of analysis is consistent?

To ensure unit of analysis consistency in management research, structurally assess whether your study treats the firm, business unit, industry, or individual as its analytic focus. Apply case-based critique to test if your empirical settings align with this focus.

What is the best way to evaluate managerial relevance in a strategy research draft?

Evaluating managerial relevance in a strategy research draft involves connecting theoretical findings to decisions managers might actually make. A structured critique highlights practical implications and ensures theoretical claims are grounded.

How do I select empirical cases for a strategy dissertation to make the research tractable?

Selecting empirical cases for a strategy dissertation requires a case-first critique that demands concrete empirical settings. This process interrogates whether the proposed case makes the research tractable, interesting, and capable of generating targeted tests.

Why does my management paper lack a clear theoretical contribution despite having case study data?

A management paper lacks a clear theoretical contribution when unit of analysis clarity and empirical case relevance are misaligned. Case-driven strategic critique identifies gaps, demands concrete settings, and ensures managerial implications ground theoretical claims.

Can I use a structured assessment to improve the empirical case selection in my management studies manuscript?

Yes, you can use a structured assessment to improve empirical case selection in management studies. Apply case-based critique to manuscript drafts to interrogate case relevance, specify the unit of analysis, and generate targeted empirical tests.

When do I need to apply case-driven strategic critique to an academic research design?

You need to apply case-driven strategic critique to an academic research design when sharpening the strategic framing of management studies. It locates the unit of analysis, demands empirical cases, and ensures managerial relevance for theoretical claims.