hostile-but-fair
CommunityRole-driven critique from inside an institution.
Content & Communication#peer-review#editorial-feedback#grant-review#hostile-but-fair#institutional-voice#ethics-board#tenure-committee
AuthorWondermonger-daydreaming
Version1.0.0
Installs0
System Documentation
What problem does it solve?
It helps users produce a rigorous, role-specific critique by inhabiting an established institutional voice rather than offering generic feedback.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Inhabit specific institutional voices (Reviewer 2, Grant Committee Member, Ethics Board, Tenure Committee, Editorial Board) to generate targeted, standards-aligned critiques.
- Provide structured, actionable feedback with role-aware blind spots and suggested improvements.
- Use in peer-review scenarios, grant reviews, or editorial decision-making to improve rigor and clarity.
Quick Start
Inhabit the chosen institutional role and generate a detailed, actionable critique of the provided claim or manuscript.
Dependency Matrix
Required Modules
None requiredComponents
Standard package💻 Claude Code Installation
Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.
Please help me install this Skill: Name: hostile-but-fair Download link: https://github.com/Wondermonger-daydreaming/claude-skills-library/archive/main.zip#hostile-but-fair Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.
Agent Skills Search Helper
Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 510,000+ vetted skills library on demand.